Pilot audit — top 20 unsent pages

Aug 11 2026 · ranked by lifetime spend. Each client’s name is a link — click it to open that person’s live preview page in a new tab.
117 FAIL · 27 need your ruling · 131 REPORT · 235 PASS (PASS hidden below). Nothing has been changed or published.

#1 Natalie Kimball

$58,927 lifetime · cash-urgent

1 FAIL1 EXCEPTION?11 REPORT

Open Natalie’s page →

Set analysis — REPORT
Page claims: None. Page states only 'Your set is +20 to +45' (a cents range; no scale or chord is named — old sweep template has no set-analysis section).
Recomputed: 15 owned bowls (incl. other-list 12" G+25, 9" C#+20, 8" E+35; no owned_overrides entry) = 10 pitch classes: C, C#, D, D#, E, F#, G, G#, A, A# — near-chromatic, missing only F and B. Exact majors C, D, D#, F#, G#, A; exact minors C, C#, D#, F#, G, A. Cents range +20 (7" C+20 / 9" C#+20) to +45 (12" D+45) — page's range claim is correct.

FAIL	R6 sections/coverage	7" G#0 Tibetan Quartz Copper Pyramid SuperGrade + minis/forks/pyramids sections present, but coverage rule broken ('cover the range, don't sample it'): the ACTIVE, window-exempt 7" G#0 pyramid (she owns two G# bowls) is missing. ACTIVE minis 5" A#-20, 4" G#0/4" G+20 double, 5" F#0/5" E+15 double also qualify by note but hang on the open R6 mini-window question.
EXCEPTION?	A2 window (practitioner)	5" E+10, 4" B+10 Mini Supergrade Double Practitioner Bowl, Tibetan Quartz Copper, Aqua Aura Gold E+10 is 10 under the +20 edge; practitioner/mini window treatment is OPEN per R6/§E6 — route to ML.
REPORT	A2 window	18" C#+15 Supergrade Bowl, Grandmother, Aqua Aura Gold (Rim) 5 under the +20 edge (band: over by <=5). It is a 2nd-octave deep SuperGrade but the section copy has NO listen-by-ear line (Rules 10b/check_window require 'ear'/'listen'); near-boundary = judgment per R1, so REPORT not auto-FAIL — ML to re-lane.
REPORT	A2 window	Owned core itself spans 25c (+20..+45), 5 past R1's 20c total pairwise span; both regular recs otherwise sit inside it (16" G+40 SuperGrade in range).
REPORT	A3 octaves	All 8 rec-card octaves match live Shopify tags (12" C+40 fork and 10" D#+30 pyramid are genuinely untagged on Shopify — blank card is correct, ask ML). But most OWNED cards show no octave (only 9" A+25 = 3rd, list G+25 = 3rd, C#+20 = 4th); untagged owned bowls need ML octaves.
REPORT	A4 names	Card names match live titles; cosmetic boilerplate-strip residue only ('Supergrade , Grandmother…', 'Mini SuperGrade Practitioner , Androgynous Indium').
REPORT	A4/data	12" D+45 Green Goddess, White Light Aura (Inside)-labeled G Owned card renders the raw inventory annotation '-labeled G' — the physical label apparently says G while the page computes with D+45; confirm note with ML before send.
REPORT	A6 offer copy	Tiered offer runs with no expiry ('going back soon', no until date) — R5: nothing open-ended while a discount runs.
REPORT	Alchemy duplication	Three recs repeat the owned Grandmother alchemy (16" G+40, 18" C#+15, 10" D#+30 pyramid) vs her 2 owned Grandmother bowls — 'never offer an alchemy the client already owns' vs the deeper-octave design; ML to judge (cf. §D7 Marsha pattern).
REPORT	Cross-page collisions	12" C+40 fork also on Paula + Erin; 4" A+40 mini on Paula; 6" A#+45 pyramid on Erin; 5" E+10/4" B+10 double on Diana — first come first served by design, tracked for SOLD-stamping.
REPORT	Status	Status.md §E7 unresolved: Natalie is now a CT partner and the old table says UNPUBLISHED, but the page IS live on Shopify.
REPORT	B16 H1	H1 'Bowls for Natalie' — last name missing (memory house rule; REPORT lane per §C).
REPORT	B15 engine copy	Offer paragraph is the older sweep text ('1 bowl is 10% off… Take two or more… comes down 10% too') — deviates from client_page.py's current verbatim tiered copy ('one bowl is 10% off…', no take-two sentence).

Voice

REPORT	Bowls for Natalie ... The bowls marked Special price are ones I have on loan that are going back soon R7 — Natalie Kimball is a CT partner: drop her from this batch and mark the page BLOCKED (pending takedown). Her draft still carries active discount copy and recommendation sections she must never receive. Voice findings below that cite template-wide issues also occur on her page but are moot under R7.
EXCEPTION?	a C tuning fork / an A mini practitioner bowl / a B pyramid B2 letter vs figcaption idiom — the article sits directly before a note name, but the note is attributive ("a C tuning fork" like "a C harmonica"), not the bare-note pattern B2's example bans ("a G and a B"). Template-wide: same captions on 17 of the 20 pages (all except diana-alcomendas, candice-sutnick uses one, melissa-helwig none). Rule seems not written for this construction — ML to rule once.

#2 Paula Harrison

$34,401 lifetime · cash-urgent

4 FAIL1 EXCEPTION?8 REPORT

Open Paula’s page →

Set analysis — FAIL
Page claims: None. Page states only 'Your set is -20 to +45' (cents range; no scale or chord named).
Recomputed: Owned notes C, D, F, G, A, B (10 bowls). They form a COMPLETE F major pentatonic (F, G, A, C, D), plus F major (F, A, C), G major (G, B, D), D minor (D, F, A), F major 6 (F, A, C, D) and D minor 7 (D, F, A, C). The page claims none of these — a textbook core goes unnamed.

FAIL	A1 exact match missed	A1/Rules 1: page misses exact matches — her 6 notes are a complete F major pentatonic (F, G, A, C, D) with F major, G major, D minor triads, yet the page identifies no core at all (old sweep template lacks the set-analysis section).
FAIL	A5 active/unsold	4" B+40 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner Bowl, Ebony Aura Gold + 5" F+5 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner Bowl, Tibetan Quartz Copper Aura Both ARCHIVED (sold) on live Shopify yet shown as live, linked, badged recs — 2 of her 5 recommendations. Rules 14b-c: SOLD card marked in place; page unsent so lane FIX-THEN-PUBLISH per R2 (rebuild before sending), never BLOCKED.
FAIL	R6 sections	No SuperGrades / deeper-octave section anywhere on the page — R6: every proposal includes SuperGrades (forks/pyramids/minis section is present).
FAIL	Owned ordering	Rules 13: same-note-same-cents bowls must show larger size first — the 6" C+45 is listed before the 9" C+45.
EXCEPTION?	A2 window (practitioner)	Minis far out of window: 4" B+40 vs owned B0/B-15 (40-55c off); 5" F+5 vs owned F+40 (35c off). Practitioner/mini window treatment OPEN per R6/§E6.
REPORT	A1 owned-set data	bowls_master client_tab rows with garbage titles ('2+1' 8" E+45, '1.0' 7" G+45) suggest possibly-real bowls missing from the page's owned list — parse artifacts, ask ML.
REPORT	A2 window	Owned span is 65c (-20..+45) treated as one tuning ('Your set is -20 to +45'); R1 scattered-set rule wants a core cluster identified — though no regular bowls are offered, so nothing was squeezed into it.
REPORT	A3 octaves	All 5 rec-card octaves match live tags (C+40 fork untagged on Shopify — blank correct). Owned cards show NO octaves at all — untagged, ask ML.
REPORT	A6 offer copy	Discount running with no expiry stated — R5 open-ended flag.
REPORT	Recommendations	Zero regular bowl recs (only exempt forms). An E would complete C major (C, E, G) and A minor (A, C, E) with owned notes; likely no special-priced in-window stock at build time — surface to ML.
REPORT	B16 H1	H1 'Bowls for Paula' — last name missing.
REPORT	B15 engine copy	Older sweep offer text (numerals + 'Take two or more…' sentence) vs client_page.py current verbatim copy.
REPORT	Cross-page collisions	Shares 11" B+40 pyramid, 4" B+40 mini (SOLD) and 5" F+5 mini (SOLD) with Erin; 12" C+40 fork with Natalie + Erin; 4" A+40 mini with Natalie.

Voice

REPORT	reduced: 1 bowl is 10% off, 2 bowls 12% off, 3 or more 15% off. Take two or more of the special price bowls, and any other bowl you add comes down 10% too ... there's nothing to check out here B15 — intro/offer block on 19 of 20 pages (all but diana-alcomendas) is an older rev, not client_page.py verbatim: engine says "one bowl is 10% off, two bowls 12% off, three or more 15% off" with "there is", and has no "Take two or more…" sentence (that wording is grandfathered only on Anne Aurigue's bespoke page, §D5). The "Listen with headphones for the truest sound…" / "first come, first served" intro also differs from the engine intro. Deviations = REPORT; new sentences need ML.
REPORT	ones I have on loan that are going back soon R5 / A6 — a tiered discount is running on all 20 pages and no page states an expiry (no `until` rendered anywhere); "going back soon" is the only time cue. ML wants time limits while a discount runs, mechanism TBD — flagging template-wide rather than per-page FAIL since no recorded per-client `until` was found to violate.

#3 Diana Alcomendas

$32,862 lifetime · cash-urgent

6 FAIL2 EXCEPTION?4 REPORT

Open Diana’s page →

Set analysis — FAIL
Page claims: 'Your six bowls are an F major scale (F, G, A, A#, C, D, E) missing only the A'; tuning 0 to +20; majors C major (C, E, G) and A# major (A#, D, F); minor G minor (G, A#, D); G minor 7 (G, A#, D, F); one note (A) from an F major pentatonic; adding an A completes the scale, F major pentatonic, F major (F, A, C) and D minor (D, F, A).
Recomputed: Owned E+20, A#+5, C+10, D0, F+10, G+5 (matches bowls_master; no overrides). Every stated claim verifies, and the F-scale-missing-A framing is correct. But the set ALSO forms an exact A# major 6 (A#, D, F, G) — analyze_set would emit it; the page omits it. (C major pentatonic is equally one-note-away; the F-pent choice is the coherent one, not an error.)

FAIL	A1 exact match missed	'What's already in your set' omits the exact A# major 6 (A#, D, F, G) her six bowls form — A1: misses an exact match. All other claims recompute correctly.
FAIL	A6 badges	Discount is ACTIVE (offer paragraph live, referencing 'bowls marked Special price') yet ZERO badges on the page. Unpaid-batch bowls unbadged: 16" A#+15 SuperGrade (Nov-25, $18,698), 12" F+15 Lemon Angel Gold (Nov-25), 5" E+10/4" B+10 double mini (Nov-25, $6,417), 12" A#+15 Androgynous Indium (Aug-24), 6" A+20 Morganite (Aug-24), 10" G+15 Platinum (Aug-24) — batch bowl missing its badge on a discount page = FAIL (Aileen SALE_SUBS precedent). Page is live-not-sent, safe to fix.
FAIL	A3 deeper heading	12" A#+15 Androgynous Indium Tagged 3rd octave on live Shopify — the SAME tagged octave as her 3rd-octave 9" A#+5 — but sits under 'A deeper A#' with copy 'These drop lower, both at +15'. Every bowl under a deeper heading must be tagged deeper.
FAIL	R6 coverage	'Practitioner bowls, tuning forks and pyramids' section contains no fork and no pyramid. ACTIVE, window-exempt qualifiers omitted: 12" C+40 Sage Aura Gold fork (owns C), 12" E+30 Violet Flame Aura fork (owns E), 6" A#+45 Green Heart Aura Gold pyramid (owns A#) — 'cover the range, don't sample it'. ACTIVE minis (4" A+40, 5" A#-20, 5" F#0/5" E+15 double) qualify by note but are far outside her 0..+20 tuning — hang on the open R6 mini-window question.
FAIL	B7 banned marks	Em dashes in headings 'A — the note that completes your set' (incl. the See-more summary) and 'One you already know — the Rose Quartz Palladium'; semicolon in prose 'not quite right for you then; if anything has changed…'. (Semicolons inside the chords list are engine-standard analyze_set output, not flagged.)
FAIL	B1 notes in parens	Bare 'You own an F major scale missing only the A' (Grow section) and 'as the root of your F major' (deeper-F note) carry no note parentheses — B1 requires them after EVERY chord/scale name, hand-written included.
EXCEPTION?	A6 Apr-25 vs >=5k	12" G+25 Rose Quartz, Palladium ($5,499) Apr-25 consignment (never special) but >=$5,000 (price_5k hand rule says special) — two sanctioned sources point different ways, §E5; currently unbadged, consistent with Apr-25-never.
EXCEPTION?	B11/§E4 theory wording	'pentatonic' (three uses) and 'the root of your F major' degree wording: allowed per Rules 17c, banned per the newer plain-spoken memory — per-client call for ML (files win, so not FAIL).
REPORT	A2 window	12" G+25 Rose Quartz, Palladium 5 over the 0..+20 window (band: over by <=5), explicitly disclosed on the page ('It is just above your tuning at +25') and a client-history bowl — near-boundary judgment per R1.
REPORT	A6 offer copy	Tiered offer has no 'until' expiry — R5 open-ended flag while a discount runs.
REPORT	B17 catalog descriptions	Popover descriptions (catalog-sourced) carry unattributed health claims ('relieves stress and depression', 'thyroid support') and anti-AI vocabulary ('especially resonant') — Shopify catalog text, not page copy; scope question for ML. Chakra lines are the engine-standard 'Said to align with…' (§E3) and all match the note map.
REPORT	Cross-page collisions	5" E+10/4" B+10 double mini also recommended on Natalie's page (first come, first served by design).

Voice

FAIL	A — the note that completes your set B7 — em dash in copy; twice: this section heading (repeated in its "See 1 more" toggle) and "One you already know — the Rose Quartz Palladium". ("completes" itself is house wording on approved pages — not flagged.)
FAIL	the look was not quite right for you then; if anything has changed, it is yours to reconsider B7 — semicolon in hand-written prose (personal note section), no engine-default cover.
EXCEPTION?	Major chords: C major (C, E, G); A# major (A#, D, F). B7 vs B15 — this semicolon is client_page.py engine-default output (the "What's already in your set" list joins entries with '; '). Two sanctioned sources point different ways: B7 bans semicolons, B15 protects engine-verbatim copy. ML to pick the separator once (engine change, not a page fix).

#4 Melissa Helwig

$30,538 lifetime

4 FAIL1 EXCEPTION?6 REPORT

Open Melissa’s page →

Set analysis — REPORT
Page claims: Heading reasons only: 'D (completes a minor chord with your F and A)' and 'D# (completes a minor chord with your C and G)'. No set-level scale/chord claim (old sweep template).
Recomputed: Owned real bowls: 10" C-40, 7" G-35, 12" F-25, 10" A-30, 7" A-45 (notes C, F, G, A). D+F+A = D minor — correct; D#+C+G = C minor — correct (engine names quality not root by design). Note: she ALREADY owns an exact F major triad (F, A, C); the page never says so.

FAIL	A1/A4 phantom duplicates	'Other bowls in your collection' lists three phantom bowls parsed from SKU-prefixed rows: 14.0" C-40 ('144615 10\" C-40 Platinum'), 13.0" A-45 ('139359 7\" A-45 Moldavite, Platinum'), 14.0" A-30 ('145547 10\" A-30 Mother Of Platinum') — the same three bowls as her 10" C-40 / 7" A-45 / 10" A-30 with sizes read from SKU digits (bowls_master rows are flagged 'custom-line: verify bowl'). Owned cards also render SKUs inside the alchemy line ('Platinum 144615', 'Kunzite, Palladium 132818') — names not cleaned per A4.
FAIL	A2 window	Band over by <=10: 8" D-15 Great Salt Lake Salt (badged), 8" D#-15 Charcoal Platinum, 8" D#-15 Apophyllite Green Heart Aura Gold are 10 past the -25 edge (30c pairwise from her A-45, vs R1's 20c). The section line 'choose ones within 20 cents of each other' is selection guidance, not a by-ear line, and does not cover 10-over bowls.
FAIL	A5 active/unsold	9" D-40 Platinum, Grandmother (Base) ARCHIVED (sold) on live Shopify but shown live, linked, badged. Rules 14b-c: SOLD card in place; unsent draft, so FIX-THEN-PUBLISH per R2.
FAIL	R6 sections	No SuperGrades/deeper-octave section AND no minis/forks/pyramids section — both required on every proposal (R6). ACTIVE qualifying items exist for the latter (12" C+40 fork — she owns C; 4" A+40 mini — she owns A).
EXCEPTION?	A6 Apr-25 vs >=5k	Apr-25 bowls >=$5,000 unbadged: 12" D#-30 Turquoise Platinum Frosted Rim ($5,978), 8" D#-25 Lemon Angel Gold w/Gold Yantra ($7,168) — Apr-25-never vs price_5k hand rule, §E5 conflict for ML.
REPORT	A2 window	Band over by <=5 (near-boundary judgment per R1): 8" D-50 (C#+50) Egyptian Blue, 8" D#-50 (D+50) Lemurian Seed, 8" D#-20 Azeztulite Pink Aura Gold Morph, 9" D#-20 Peridot Platinum — each 5 past an owned edge (-45..-25 window).
REPORT	A3 octaves	All rec-card octaves match live tags (8" D-50 genuinely untagged, blank correct); owned 12" F-25 card shows no octave — untagged, ask ML.
REPORT	A4 tag mismatch	8" D#-20 Azeztulite, Pink Aura Gold Morph Live Shopify cents tag reads '-15 while the title says -20 — tag/title mismatch on the product itself; heads-up to ML (title is truth, card matches title).
REPORT	A6 offer copy	Discount running with no expiry stated — R5 open-ended flag.
REPORT	B16 H1	H1 'Bowls for Melissa' — last name missing.
REPORT	B15 engine copy	Older sweep offer text vs client_page.py current verbatim copy.

#5 Erin Forsyth

$30,381 lifetime · cash-urgent

4 FAIL2 EXCEPTION?7 REPORT

Open Erin’s page →

Set analysis — REPORT
Page claims: None. Page states only 'Your set is -40 to +40' (cents range; no scale or chord named; deeper-octave headings carry no chord reasoning).
Recomputed: 13 owned bowls (5 cards + 8 other-list) = 9 pitch classes: C, D, E, F, G, G#, A, A#, B (missing C#, D#, F#). Exact majors C, E, F, G, A#; exact minors A, D, E, G. Cents span 80 (E-40 … G+40/C+30) — a scattered set under R1. Range claim -40 to +40 is correct.

FAIL	A2 window structure	R1: the 80c owned span is treated as ONE window and the G# recs alone span 90c (10" G#-45 to 16" G#+45). R1 requires building around the densest cluster with far outliers as stand-alones/binaurals (Celeste pattern); the 'choose ones within 20 cents of each other' line is guidance, not a core. ML to re-lane against the sweep's built-at-±10 reality (§E1).
FAIL	A5 active/unsold	Three recs ARCHIVED (sold) on live Shopify but shown live, linked, badged: 10" G#0 Apophyllite, Lavender Aura Gold, Frosted Rim Inside; 4" B+40 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner, Ebony Aura Gold; 5" F+5 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner, Tibetan Quartz Copper Aura. SOLD-stamp in place / rebuild before publish (unsent draft, R2).
FAIL	A3 octave display	5" A#-20 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner, Platinum Card octave line is blank but the live product IS tagged 5th octave — missing octave display where a tag exists (A3).
FAIL	R6 coverage	12" E+30 Violet Flame Aura Tuning Fork Sections present (deeper octaves + minis/forks/pyramids) but coverage broken: the ACTIVE, window-exempt 12" E+30 fork (she owns E) is missing. ACTIVE minis 4" A+40, 5" E+10/4" B+10 double, 5" F#0/5" E+15 double also qualify by note pending the R6 mini-window ruling.
EXCEPTION?	A2 window (practitioner)	Minis far out of window: 5" A#-20 vs owned A#+25 (45c); 4" B+40 vs B-20/B-25 (60-65c); 5" F+5 vs F+25/F+35 (20-30c) — practitioner/mini window treatment OPEN per R6/§E6.
EXCEPTION?	A6 Apr-25 vs >=5k	Apr-25 bowls >=$5,000 unbadged: 12" G#-40 Peridot Platinum Transcendent ($5,538), 12" G#+10 Mother Of Platinum Laughing Buddha ($6,379), 12" E-10 Rose Quartz WLAG ($5,813) — §E5 conflict for ML.
REPORT	A2 window	Band over by <=5: 10" G#-45 Lavender Aura Gold (5 under -40) and 16" G#+45 SuperGrade Platinum AAG Base (5 over +40; 2nd-octave deep SG with NO listen-by-ear line in the section — Rules 10b wants one). Near-boundary judgment per R1.
REPORT	A1 duplicate bowl	Card '9" B-20 Abalone, Platinum' AND other-list '9" B-25 Abalone, Platinum (changed from 20)' appear to be the SAME bowl with conflicting cents — ask ML which measurement stands (range claim unaffected).
REPORT	A4 display style	0-cent cards render '+0' (12" G#+0, 10" G#+0 x2, 7" G#+0, 4" G#+0) where live titles use True-Tone 'G#0' (engine cfmt style '0'); other-list leaks raw correction notes to the client ('(changed from +10)', '(changed from -10)', '(changed from 20)') instead of the 'label (measures X)' style of Rules 13a.
REPORT	A6 offer copy	Discount running with no expiry stated — R5 open-ended flag.
REPORT	B16 H1	H1 'Bowls for Erin' — last name missing.
REPORT	B15 engine copy	Older sweep offer text vs client_page.py current verbatim; also template artifact heading 'See other A deeper G# options (14)' reads awkwardly (count itself is true).
REPORT	Cross-page collisions	Shares both SOLD minis (4" B+40, 5" F+5) plus 11" B+40 pyramid with Paula; 12" C+40 fork and 6" A#+45 pyramid with Natalie.

Voice

FAIL

9.0" B-25 Abalone, Platinum (changed from 20)
B6 — cents always signed: "20" is unsigned (sister notes on the same page read "(changed from +10)" and "(changed from -10)"). Should be "-20" if that is the prior label.

#6 Gayle Pulizzi

$26,138 lifetime · cash-urgent

6 FAIL1 EXCEPTION?7 REPORT

Open Gayle’s page →

Set analysis — FAIL
Page claims: None. Set section says only: "Your set is -40 to +45." (cents span, no scale/chord named)
Recomputed: Owned notes D, E, F, G, G#, A, B (no overrides for this client in owned_overrides.json). Exact matches missed: complete G major pentatonic (G, A, B, D, E) = same notes as E minor pentatonic; G major (G, B, D); E major (E, G#, B); E minor (E, G, B); D minor (D, F, A); G major 6 / E minor 7 (G, B, D, E / E, G, B, D).

FAIL	A1	Set section names no chord/scale though the owned notes form a complete G major pentatonic (G, A, B, D, E) and G major, E major, E minor, D minor triads — A1: 'misses an exact match' (Rules.md 1: identify the core).
FAIL	A3	None of the 9 owned cards shows an octave, and the sweep template has no popover or print page for them either — Rules 11a requires octave on card, popover, AND print (template-wide defect across all five pages).
FAIL	A5	4" B+40 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner Bowl, Ebony Aura Gold, Crystal Tones® Alchemy Singing Bowl Live Shopify status ARCHIVED (sold), inventory 0, yet still a live linked card with a Special price badge and no SOLD treatment. Unsent page → per R2 lane FIX-THEN-PUBLISH (rebuild immediately before sending drops it), never BLOCKED.
FAIL	A5	5" F+5 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner Bowl, Tibetan Quartz Copper Aura, Crystal Tones® Alchemy Singing Bowl Live Shopify status ARCHIVED, inventory 0, still linked with a Special price badge and no SOLD treatment. Same R2 FIX-THEN-PUBLISH note.
FAIL	R6	No SuperGrades section. R6: every proposal includes SuperGrades, tuning forks, pyramids, and mini practitioners; forks/pyramids/minis are present (combined section) but SuperGrades are absent — missing section = FAIL (fix: add it). Note the minis are labeled Mini SuperGrade, but there is no full-size SuperGrade offering.
FAIL	B2	Pick lines put a/an directly before note names: "an A mini practitioner bowl", "a B pyramid", "a B mini practitioner bowl", "an E tuning fork", "an F mini practitioner bowl", "a G# pyramid" (template-wide).
EXCEPTION?	A2	All recs are minis/forks/pyramids; forks and pyramids are window-exempt, but the mini practitioners (4" A+40 Androgynous Indium, 4" B+40 Ebony Aura Gold, 5" E+10/4" B+10 double, 5" F+5 Tibetan Quartz Copper Aura, 4" G#0/4" G+20 double) sit at 0..+40 against her -40..-15 majority cluster — out-of-window practitioner/mini bowls are the open R6/§E6 question, route to ML.
REPORT	A2	Owned set is scattered: circular pairwise span 70 cents (cents +10, -35, -30, -40, -40, +45, -15, -15, +40; largest cluster -40..-15). Page claim '-40 to +45' is literal min/max; no R1 scattered-set structure (build around the biggest cluster, outliers as binaurals/stand-alones) — but also no plain bowls recommended, so no window FAIL is chargeable.
REPORT	A6	Offer copy is open-ended — no expiry stated while a discount runs. R5: ML wants time limits, mechanism TBD; flag, don't FAIL.
REPORT	B6	Cents are signed throughout ('-40 to +45'), but zero cents renders as '+0' (7" G#+0, 4" G#+0) where titles/engine use '0' / True Tone.
REPORT	B15	Offer paragraph deviates from client_page.py discount_offer verbatim: digits '1 bowl/2 bowls/3 or more' vs 'one/two/three', added sentence 'Take two or more of the special price bowls, and any other bowl you add comes down 10% too' (that is Anne Aurigue's old bespoke offer, §D5: explicitly not a template for engine pages), and "there's" vs 'there is'. Intro copy also differs from the engine intro. New sentences need ML.
REPORT	B16	H1 is 'Bowls for Gayle' — last name missing (Aug-7 house rule wants 'Bowls for Gayle Pulizzi').
REPORT	cross-page	Owned-list duplication with Victoria Celia: 7" G-40 Lemurian Seed, Smokey Quartz Practitioner; 6" G#+45 Rose Quartz, Palladium; and 8" B+40 Tiger's Eye appear on BOTH clients' owned lists with identical photos — possible records contamination, ask ML.
REPORT	cross-page	All 8 rec items also appear on Victoria/Merisa/Molly sweep pages (first come, first served by design; tracked so sold ones get SOLD-stamped in place — the archived Ebony mini above is exactly that case, currently un-stamped on three pages).

#7 Victoria Celia

$25,342 lifetime · cash-urgent

5 FAIL1 EXCEPTION?7 REPORT

Open Victoria’s page →

Set analysis — FAIL
Page claims: None. Set section says only: "Your set is -40 to +50." (cents span, no scale/chord named)
Recomputed: Owned notes C, C#, D, E, F#, G, G#, B (13 bowls, no overrides). Exact matches missed: C major (C, E, G); E major (E, G#, B); G major (G, B, D); C# minor (C#, E, G#); E minor (E, G, B); B minor (B, D, F#); plus 4-of-5 of both C major pentatonic (missing A) and G major pentatonic (missing A).

FAIL	A1	Set section names no chord/scale though the owned notes form six exact triads (C major, E major, G major, C# minor, E minor, B minor) — A1 'misses an exact match'.
FAIL	A3	None of the 13 owned cards shows an octave; no popover/print either (Rules 11a; sweep-template-wide).
FAIL	A5	4" B+40 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner Bowl, Ebony Aura Gold, Crystal Tones® Alchemy Singing Bowl Live ARCHIVED, inventory 0, still a live linked Special-price card with no SOLD treatment. Unsent page → R2 FIX-THEN-PUBLISH (rebuild before sending).
FAIL	R6	No SuperGrades section (forks, pyramids, minis present in the combined section). R6: missing section = FAIL.
FAIL	B2	Pick lines 'a B pyramid', 'a B mini practitioner bowl', 'an E tuning fork', 'a G# pyramid', 'a C tuning fork' put a/an directly before note names.
EXCEPTION?	A2	Mini practitioners recommended across 0..+40 (B+40 Ebony mini, E+10/B+10 double, G#0/G+20 double, F#0/E+15 double) with no single 20-cent set band — out-of-window practitioner/minis per R6/§E6, route to ML. Forks (C+40, E+30) and pyramids (B+40, G#0) window-exempt.
REPORT	A2	Owned set scattered: circular pairwise span 70 cents (cents -40, -30, -20, +50, -10, -15, +35, -40, +20, -25, +45, -35, +40); '-40 to +50' claim is literal (note C#+50 and C-40 are only 10 apart circularly). No R1 cluster/outlier structure, but no plain bowls are recommended so no window FAIL chargeable.
REPORT	A3	12" C+40 Sage Aura Gold Tuning Fork Card octave blank; the live product genuinely has NO octave tag, so blank is correct — untagged = blank + REPORT to ML for tagging. All other rec octave displays match live tags.
REPORT	A6	Offer copy open-ended, no expiry while the discount runs (R5 flag).
REPORT	B6	Signed throughout, but zero cents rendered '+0' (G#+0, F#+0) vs title/engine '0'.
REPORT	B15	Same template deviation from client_page.py as Gayle: digit tiers, Anne-style 'Take two or more…' sentence (§D5 non-template copy), "there's".
REPORT	B16	H1 'Bowls for Victoria' — last name missing.
REPORT	cross-page	Owned-list duplication with Gayle Pulizzi (7" G-40 Lemurian Seed, Smokey Quartz Practitioner; 6" G#+45 Rose Quartz, Palladium; 8" B+40 Tiger's Eye — identical photos on both owned lists); all 8 recs shared with other sweep pages (first-come collisions, tracked).

Voice

REPORT

Bowls for Victoria
B16 — H1 missing last name on 19 of 20 pages (only diana-alcomendas has "Bowls for Diana Alcomendas"). Extra ambiguity: three different clients in this batch all render the identical H1 "Bowls for Victoria" (victoria-celia, victoria-wooding, victoria-deroche). REPORT lane per §C.

#8 Candice Sutnick

$24,224 lifetime · cash-urgent

7 FAIL1 EXCEPTION?5 REPORT

Open Candice’s page →

Set analysis — FAIL
Page claims: None in the set section ("Your set is -40 to -20."). Rec subheads claim: "D# (completes a major chord with your F# and B)" and "E (completes a major chord with your G# and B)".
Recomputed: Owned notes C#, F#, G#, A#, B (two 7"/12" F#-40s = same-note pair, non-error per Rules 8). The set ALREADY contains an exact F# major triad (F#, A#, C#) — unclaimed. Also 4-of-5 of B major pentatonic (B, C#, D#, F#, G#, missing the D# the page recommends) and 4-of-5 of F# major pentatonic (missing D#). Subhead math verified correct: D# completes B major (B, D#, F#); E completes E major (E, G#, B).

FAIL	A1	Set section names no chord though the owned notes form an exact F# major triad (F#, A#, C#) — A1 'misses an exact match'. The D#/E rec subheads themselves recompute correctly.
FAIL	A2	Owned range -40..-20 (exactly 20c total span, R1-clean) but recs run past the edges with NO by-ear line (the 'choose ones within 20 cents of each other' note contains no ear/listen wording check_window requires). Bands — over by ≤5: 9" D#-45 Indigo; 9" D#-45 Platinum; 9" D#-45 Ocean Indium, Platinum (Inside); 10" D#-45 Mother Of Platinum; 8" D#-15 Charcoal, Platinum; 8" D#-15 Apophyllite, Green Heart Aura Gold; 8" E-45 Grandmother; 9" E-45 Great Salt Lake Salt, Green Aura Gold; 7" E-45 Citrine, Platinum; 7" E-15 Citrine, Kyanite, Platinum. Over by ≤10: 8" D#-10 Anchi; 8" D#-50 (D+50) Lemurian Seed, Aqua Aura Gold; 12" E-10 Rose Quartz, White Light Angel Gold, Frosted (Inside) (3rd octave — not deep-exempt). Over by >10: none. §E1 caveat: the sweep was built at ±10, so every listing is within ML's audit-spec band — one-pass re-lane possible.
FAIL	A3	None of the 7 owned cards shows an octave; no popover/print (Rules 11a, template-wide).
FAIL	A3	5" A#-20 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner Bowl, Platinum, Crystal Tones® Alchemy Singing Bowl Card octave is blank but the live product IS tagged '5th octave' — missing octave display when a tag exists. All other rec octave displays match live tags.
FAIL	R6	No SuperGrades section, no tuning forks, and no pyramids — the 'Mini practitioner bowls, tuning forks, and pyramids' section holds a single A# mini. Qualifying items in her notes exist and are absent (11" B+40 Green Heart Aura Gold Pyramid — she owns B; 7" G#0 Tibetan Quartz Copper Pyramid — she owns G#), which also breaks 'cover the range, don't sample it'.
FAIL	owned-alchemy	Recs repeat alchemies she already owns (rule: never offer a note OR alchemy the client owns, no ML override recorded): 8" E-45 Grandmother vs owned 8" G#-40 Grandmother; 8" D#-15 Charcoal, Platinum vs owned 8" A#-20 Charcoal Platinum. (Partial overlaps like 12" D#-40 Advance Selenite, Pink Aura Gold vs owned 7" F#-40 Pink Aura Gold / 6" C#-30 Advance Selenite, Grandmother — judgment, folding into this line as lesser evidence.)
FAIL	B2	Pick line 'an A# mini practitioner bowl' puts 'an' directly before a note name.
EXCEPTION?	A2	Out-of-window practitioner bowls per §E6 (engine exempts, Rules 18d says 'near their tuning'): 7" D#-45 White Light Angel Gold Frosted (Inside) Practitioner (5 over); 8" E-15 Aqua Aura Marine Gold Practitioner, Tall (5 over); 7" E-50 (D#+50) Pink Ocean Gold Practitioner (10 over).
REPORT	A6	Open-ended offer while discount runs (R5). Also: ≥$5,000 bowls on this discount page carry no badge — 12" D#-30 Turquoise, Platinum Frosted Rim ($5,978), 12" E-10 Rose Quartz, White Light Angel Gold, Frosted (Inside) ($5,813), 8" D#-25 Lemon Angel Gold w/Gold Yantra ($7,168); the Aug-7 price_5k rule says these get special by hand — surface to ML, hand-rule so not auto-FAIL.
REPORT	owned-order	7.0" F#-40 Pink Aura Gold is listed before 12.0" F#-40 Grandfather — Rules 13 puts the 12" first under any octave assignment (same cents → larger first; if octaves differ the 12" is the deeper). Cannot confirm owned tags without handles; heads-up rather than FAIL.
REPORT	B15	Same offer-paragraph deviation from client_page.py as the other sweep pages (digit tiers, §D5 Anne sentence, "there's").
REPORT	B16	H1 'Bowls for Candice' — last name missing.
REPORT	cross-page	Her D# and E sections overlap Molly Holm's page almost entirely (16+ shared handles, incl. 12" E-10 Rose Quartz WLAG and 12" D#-30 Turquoise) — first come, first served by design; when one sells the others need SOLD-stamping in place.

#9 Merisa Horgan

$23,441 lifetime · cash-urgent

4 FAIL6 REPORT

Open Merisa’s page →

Set analysis — PASS
Page claims: "Your set is +25 to +45. Your bowls are a C major scale: C, D, E, F, G, A, B." (section H2: "Your C major scale")
Recomputed: Owned notes across 22 bowls (5 carded + 17 in the other-bowls list): C, D, E, F, G, A, B — a complete C major scale; cents +25..+45 confirmed from every listed bowl. Claim matches recomputation exactly (contains C major, F major, G major, A minor, D minor, E minor, C major pentatonic — page names the parent scale, which is the fuller equivalent).

FAIL	A3	None of the 5 owned cards shows an octave; no popover/print (Rules 11a, template-wide).
FAIL	A5	4" B+40 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner Bowl, Ebony Aura Gold, Crystal Tones® Alchemy Singing Bowl Live ARCHIVED, inventory 0, still a live linked Special-price card with no SOLD treatment (same bowl is also live on Gayle's and Victoria's drafts). Unsent → R2 FIX-THEN-PUBLISH.
FAIL	R6	No SuperGrades section — and Merisa is an established collector (22 bowls; Rules 4b explicitly wants SuperGrades for established collectors). Forks, pyramid, minis present. Note: with all 7 scale notes owned, the absent 'bowls that pair' section is explainable (no new note to offer); the SuperGrades gap (deeper octaves of owned notes) is not.
FAIL	B2	Pick lines 'a C tuning fork', 'an E tuning fork', 'an A mini practitioner bowl', 'a B pyramid', 'a B mini practitioner bowl' put a/an directly before note names.
REPORT	A3	Other-bowls list shows octaves on only 2 of 17 entries (9" A+45 Advance Selenite, Aqua Aura Gold · 3rd octave; 8" A+30 Mother of Platinum · 4th octave); the rest are blank — missing octave data, ask ML (Rules 11c digits from the client doc). Also 12" C+40 Sage Aura Gold Tuning Fork octave blank because the live product is untagged (blank correct; needs a tag).
REPORT	A6	Open-ended offer copy while the discount runs (R5 flag).
REPORT	B9	'Your bowls ARE a C major scale' skirts B9's bowls-are-IN-a-scale rule (engine analyze_set says 'Together they make a complete…'); the '+25 to +45' cents half is the approved pattern. Borderline — surface, not FAIL.
REPORT	B15	Same offer-paragraph deviation from client_page.py (digit tiers, §D5 Anne sentence, "there's"); scale line uses colon-list instead of engine parens format.
REPORT	B16	H1 'Bowls for Merisa' — last name missing.
REPORT	cross-page	All 5 recs shared with Gayle/Victoria/Molly drafts (first-come collisions by design; the shared Ebony mini has now sold — needs SOLD-stamp or rebuild on every carrying page).

Music check — REFUTED
Minis section: "The doubles are binaural, two close notes that beat gently against each other."
The only same-note pair in that section is the 11" B+40 Green Heart Aura Gold Pyramid and the 4" B+40 Ebony Aura Gold mini practitioner. Live Shopify tags confirm 3rd octave vs 5th octave: two full octaves (2400 cents) apart, so they are not 'two close notes' and cannot beat against each other. The page carries no actual 'Double Practitioner … Binaural' product, so the sentence is either false about the visible B+40 pair (which house Rules.md 8 defines as a 'double') or refers to nothing; uncertainty refutes. Everything else on the page holds: owned notes (C+45, D+45, F+45, G+45, B+30 plus the other-list A/E/B bowls) contain exactly C, D, E, F, G, A, B = C major scale, and the stated +25 to +45 range matches min E+25/A+25 and max +45.

Music check — REFUTED
Minis section: "The doubles are binaural, two close notes that beat gently against each other."
The scale claim itself is solid (from-us bowls alone are C+45, D+45, E+25, F+45, G+45, A+45, B+30 = all seven C major notes; cents +25 to +45 as stated). But the binaural claim fails: her minis section contains no Double Practitioner product, so the only 'doubles' a reader can map the sentence to are the 11" B+40 pyramid and the 4" B+40 mini practitioner — live Shopify tags confirm 3rd octave vs 5th octave. Two B+40s two octaves apart are an octave relation (~4x frequency), not 'two close notes that beat gently against each other'; binaural beating requires nearly identical frequencies (cf. Mira's sanctioned pair: two 8" C# bowls 20 cents apart, same octave). On every other audited page this sentence has a true referent (a Mini Supergrade Double Practitioner product, picks labeled 'binaural'); here it is false as applied. Side notes for other lanes: the 4" B+40 mini is ARCHIVED live (A5); the 'Other bowls in your collection' list absorbs client_tab 'Interested in'/'All the bowls she looked at' wishlist rows (ownership-data REPORT), though the scale and +25-to-+45 claims hold on from-us bowls alone.

#10 Molly Holm

$22,613 lifetime · cash-urgent

16 FAIL3 EXCEPTION?7 REPORT

Open Molly’s page →

Set analysis — PASS
Page claims: None in the set section ("Your set is -35 to +40."). Rec subheads claim: "C# (completes a minor chord with your F# and A)", "D (completes a major chord with your F# and A)", "C (C is the perfect 4th of your G)", "B (B is the perfect 4th of your F#)", "D# (D# is the perfect 5th of your G#)", "E (E is the perfect 5th of your A)".
Recomputed: Owned notes F#, G, G#, A (6 bowls; F#+30/F#+40 same-note pair = non-error per Rules 8) — a chromatic cluster with NO triad and no ≥4-of-5 pentatonic, so claiming nothing is correct. Subhead math all verified: C# completes F# minor (F#, A, C#); D completes D major (D, F#, A); C is the fourth above G; B the fourth above F#; D# the fifth above G#; E the fifth above A — directions correct (Rules 17c).

FAIL	A3	None of the 6 owned cards shows an octave; no popover/print (Rules 11a, template-wide).
FAIL	A3	12" D+0 Laughing Buddha, Frosted Rim Inside, Crystal Tones® Alchemy Singing Bowl Card shows '4th octave' but the live Shopify tag is '3rd octave' — octave display contradicts the tag (tags are the only octave source).
FAIL	A4	Eight jewelry rings carry fabricated bowl-style names with size/note/cents that do NOT exist in their titles: card '13" E+9 Moldavite Ring M13, Size 9' vs live title 'Moldavite Ring M13, Size 9' — likewise 9" E+8 Moldavite Ring M9, 10" E+9 Moldavite Ring M10, 8" E+8 Moldavite Ring M8, 7" E+8 Amber Ring A7, 6" E+9 Moldavite Ring M6, 4" E+10 Amazonite Ring A4, 4" E+8 Moldavite Ring M4. Names not from titles, and rings are recommended as tuned instruments inside the E bowls section.
FAIL	A5	8" C#+40 Amethyst Tall Bowl, Crystal Tones® Alchemy Singing Bowl Live ARCHIVED, inventory 0, still a live linked Special-price card, no SOLD treatment. (All ten A5 fails: unsent page → R2 FIX-THEN-PUBLISH; rebuild drops them.)
FAIL	A5	7" C#-15 Indigo, Platinum Practitioner Crystal Tones® Alchemy Singing Bowl Live ARCHIVED, still linked with Special-price badge.
FAIL	A5	9" C+5 Tesseract Salt, Platinum, Crystal Tones® Alchemy Singing Bowl Live ARCHIVED, still linked with Special-price badge.
FAIL	A5	9" D-40 Platinum, Grandmother (Base), Crystal Tones® Alchemy Singing Bowl Live ARCHIVED, still linked with Special-price badge.
FAIL	A5	8" D+40 Grandmother, Crystal Tones® Alchemy Singing Bowl Live ARCHIVED, still linked with Special-price badge.
FAIL	A5	8" D+35 Black Tourmaline Crystal Tones® Alchemy Singing Bowl Live ARCHIVED, still linked (unbadged). This is the bowl Caroline De Pauw is buying as her second tuning (owned_overrides note) — likely why it archived; also a live cross-page collision.
FAIL	A5	7" D+15 Larimar Tall Bowl Crystal Tones® Alchemy Singing Bowl Live ARCHIVED, still linked (unbadged).
FAIL	A5	12" D#+10 White Light Aura Gold, Crystal Tones® Alchemy Singing Bowl Live ARCHIVED, still linked with Special-price badge and a '(measures +20)' annotation; also carries Alexandra Hodovanu's rec_shift override — collision now moot, needs SOLD handling everywhere it appears.
FAIL	A5	8" D#0 Monroe-Utah Hot Springs, Palladium Bowl Crystal Tones® Alchemy Singing Bowl Live ARCHIVED, still linked (unbadged).
FAIL	A5	10" B+40 Phenacite, Platinum, Crystal Tones® Alchemy Singing Bowl Live ARCHIVED, still linked with Special-price badge.
FAIL	R6	No SuperGrades section. The minis/forks/pyramids section has minis and a G# pyramid but NO tuning fork — no fork exists in her owned notes (F#/G/G#/A; catalog forks are C+40 and E+30), so the fork gap is a data gap to surface rather than a build error, but the SuperGrades section is squarely missing per R6.
FAIL	owned-alchemy	Rec 8" D#0 Monroe-Utah Hot Springs, Palladium repeats the alchemy of her owned 8" F#+30 Monroe, Utah Hot Springs (no ML override recorded; bowl is also archived). Near-misses to eyeball: 9" D-40 / 10" C-40 Platinum, Grandmother (Base) vs owned 6" G-30 Grandmother, Platinum (Outside); 9" C#-15 / 9" D+15 Tesseract Salt, Palladium vs owned 10" G-20 Tesseract Salt, Platinum Tall.
FAIL	B2	Pick lines 'an A mini practitioner bowl', 'a G# pyramid' put a/an directly before note names.
EXCEPTION?	A2	Owned set is scattered per R1: circular span 50 cents, two 3-bowl clusters (-35..-20 vs +30..+40, a dead tie for 'what they have the most of'). Instead of R1's Celeste structure (pick a core cluster, outliers as stand-alones) the page offers EVERY cents value per note (C# section alone spans -40..+45, ~85c) with the self-select line 'choose ones within 20 cents of each other' — no written rule covers this structure and no window is definable to band against; ML to rule which cluster is the core and whether self-select is acceptable.
EXCEPTION?	A6	Moldavite Ring M13, Size 9 Carries a Special price badge but is $196 jewelry — no unpaid-batch row, not Divine-titled, not ≥$5,000, no recorded ML force-pick. Unexplained non-batch badge → EXCEPTION? per A6.
EXCEPTION?	B11	Bare interval subheads with no explanation or attribution: 'C (C is the perfect 4th of your G)', 'B (B is the perfect 4th of your F#)', 'D# (D# is the perfect 5th of your G#)', 'E (E is the perfect 5th of your A)'. Per §E4/R4 interval wording is EXCEPTION? not FAIL (files win over the chords-only memory), and R4 wants human explanation with attribution for a client with no known music background; all four directions are correct (Rules 17c satisfied).
REPORT	A3	10" B+10 Platinum octave blank — live tag exists but in nonstandard form '3rd' (not '3rd octave'), so the builder missed it; fix the tag. Correctly-blank untagged products to tag: 10" D0 Moldavite; 9" D#0 Lemurian Seed, Pink Aura Gold, Frosted (Inside); 8" E+10 Dead Sea Salt, Aqua Aura Gold (also missing the standard _Crystal Tones tags); 8" D#0 Monroe-Utah Hot Springs, Palladium.
REPORT	A4	Title/tag cents disagreements on recs (title is truth, but the sign-confirming tag disagrees): 7" B-45 Black Tourmaline tagged '-30; 8" D#-20 Azeztulite, Pink Aura Gold Morph tagged '-15; 9" D#+20 Pink Aura Gold, Sacred Feminine Kudaka Island Salt tagged '+25; 9" E+20 Moldavite tagged '-35 on handle 9-c-35-moldavite (handle≠title is normal per §D6, the tag conflict is not). '+0' zero-rendering (12" D+0, 10" B+0, 8" D#+0, G#+0 cards) vs title '0' — cosmetic.
REPORT	A6	Open-ended offer while the discount runs (R5). Unbadged ≥$5k bowls on this discount page (Aug-7 hand-special rule, surface to ML): 12" B+5 Itoigawa Jade ($5,224); 12" C-15 White Alchemy Gold, Palladium (Inside) ($5,939); 12" D#-30 Turquoise, Platinum Frosted Rim ($5,978); 12" E-10 Rose Quartz, White Light Angel Gold, Frosted (Inside) ($5,813); 6" D+10 Egyptian Blue, Platinum w/Gold Divine Flower of Life ($7,392); 8" D#-25 Lemon Angel Gold w/Gold Yantra ($7,168).
REPORT	B6	Signed throughout; zero cents rendered '+0' (12" D+0, 10" B+0, 8" D#+0, 4"/7" G#+0) vs title/engine '0'.
REPORT	B15	Same offer-paragraph deviation from client_page.py as the other sweep drafts (digit tiers, §D5 Anne 'Take two or more…' sentence, "there's").
REPORT	B16	H1 'Bowls for Molly' — last name missing.
REPORT	cross-page	Heavy first-come collisions by design: her D#/E sections overlap Candice Sutnick's page (16+ shared handles), minis/pyramid shared with Gayle/Victoria/Merisa, 12" D#+10 WLAG shared with Alexandra Hodovanu's recs. Also the 5" F#0, 5" E+15 double practitioner sits under 'notes from your set' though E is only a recommended note for her, not an owned one.

Music check — UPHELD

Owned: F#+30, F#+40, G-30, G-20, G#-35, A+30; stated range -35 to +40 matches. Every section claim recomputes: C#+F#+A = F# minor (3+4 semitones); D+F#+A = D major (4+3); C is the perfect 4th of G (5 semitones); B is the perfect 4th of F# (5); D# is the perfect 5th of G# (7); E is the perfect 5th of A (7). The minis binaural line has true referents (5" F#+0 and 4" G#+0 Double Practitioner Binaural products), and every mini/fork/pyramid note (A, F#, G#) is in her set. The 8" E+50 shown as (F-50) is the same pitch by circular cents and is transparently double-labeled.

Music check — UPHELD

Owned: F#+30, F#+40, G-30, G-20, G#-35, A+30 (matches bowls_master; no overrides). '-35 to +40' correct. No triad, no 4-note chord, and no >=4/5 pentatonic exists in {F#, G, G#, A} (four consecutive semitones), so the plain 'Your set' heading with no chord claim is right — nothing missed. C# completes F# minor (F#, A, C#) with owned F#+A: correct. D completes D major (D, F#, A) with owned F#+A: correct. C = perfect 4th of G (5 semitones up): correct and direction-correct; B = perfect 4th of F#: correct; D# = perfect 5th of G# (7 semitones): correct; E = perfect 5th of A: correct. All six 'span more than 20 cents' lines true (spans 85-95, also circularly). Both binaural picks sit on actual Mini Supergrade Double Practitioner products. Minor note, not a refutation: the section banner 'Each note below makes a chord with bowls you already own' covers the four interval-only sections (C, B, D#, E) where the added note forms only a dyad (open 4th/5th) with owned notes, no triad — defensible as loose chord language and each heading states the true relationship, but ML may want the banner softened; interval wording is EXCEPTION? lane per checklist E4 regardless.

Voice

FAIL

C (C is the perfect 4th of your G)
R4 — bare interval names as recommendation reasoning, no explanation/attribution. Four headings: "C (C is the perfect 4th of your G)", "B (B is the perfect 4th of your F#)", "D# (D# is the perfect 5th of your G#)", "E (E is the perfect 5th of your A)". All four are direction-correct per Rules 17c, so the fix is explanation only (e.g. the "said to be…" pattern) or a chord/plain restatement.

#11 Jennifer Doyle

$19,422 lifetime · cash-urgent

5 FAIL1 EXCEPTION?11 REPORT

Open Jennifer’s page →

Set analysis — FAIL
Page claims: No set-level chord/scale named — header says only 'Your set is -35 to +45'; the one rec heading claims 'G (completes a minor chord with your D and A#)'
Recomputed: G+D+A# = G minor (G, A#, D) — completion claim correct. But owned notes {C, D, E, F, A, A#} (after no owned_overrides for her) already form F major (F, A, C), A# major (A#, D, F), D minor (D, F, A), A minor (A, C, E), F major 6 (F, A, C, D), F major 7 (F, A, C, E), A# major 7 (A#, D, F, A), D minor 7 (D, F, A, C), and 4 of 5 of a C major pentatonic (missing G)

FAIL	A1	Rules.md 1 / A1: page misses exact matches — the set already forms F major (F, A, C), D minor (D, F, A), A minor (A, C, E), F major 7 (F, A, C, E) etc. and none is named; the G-minor completion itself recomputes correctly
FAIL	A3	10" G-25 Mt. Shasta Serpentine, Sedona Red Rock, White Light Angel Gold Card shows '4th octave'; live Shopify tag is 3rd octave
FAIL	A3	5" A#-20 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner, Platinum Card octave blank; live tag is 5th octave (Jul-21 cache stale — refresh before publish)
FAIL	A5	5" F+5 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner Bowl, Tibetan Quartz Copper Aura Live status ARCHIVED (sold) but still a linked, Special-price card with no red Sold mark; page is UNSENT so per R2 lane = FIX-THEN-PUBLISH (rebuild immediately before sending)
FAIL	Sections (R6)	No SuperGrades section (minis, forks and a pyramid are present); R6 requires all four on every proposal
EXCEPTION?	A6	Unbadged but eligible under the Aug-7 price_5k rule: 7" G-5 Divine Blissful Transformation Tall ($5,004, Divine), 7" G-35 Platinum w/Gold Etched Ring Of Light Practitioner ($6,211), 12" G+25 Rose Quartz, Palladium ($5,499) — all three are also Apr-25 consignment which A6 says never badge; two sanctioned sources conflict (E5), ML to rule
REPORT	A2	Owned set spans 80 cents (-35 to +45) — scattered set per R1; page offers one G row spanning -35..+50 with the 'choose ones within 20 cents of each other' line instead of building around a core cluster; route structure to ML
REPORT	A2	10" G+50 (G#-50) Citrine Transcendent 5c past the +45 edge (band <=5); the >20c span line is present but Rules 7's plain by-ear line is not
REPORT	A3	Untagged live, blank shown correctly (ask ML to tag): 7" G+40 Laughing Buddha Practitioner; 12" C+40 Sage Aura Gold Tuning Fork
REPORT	A3	All 6 owned cards + 5 other-list bowls show no octave; their archived products carry no octave tags live — Rules 11a wants octave on every owned bowl, ask ML to tag
REPORT	A4	7" G+15 Advance Selenite, Sage Aura Gold Live tag says '+20 (handle also g-20) while the title says G+15 — tag/title conflict for ML; also zero-cent card renders 'G+0' where the title reads 'G0', and the 5" E+10 double practitioner size line drops the 4" B+10 half of the title
REPORT	A6	Offer copy 'on loan that are going back soon' has no expiry date while the discount runs — R5 wants a time limit
REPORT	Binaural	9" A#-15 Lemurian Seed + 6" A#-15 Sugilite are a same-note pair (intentional binaural per Rules 8) but carry no binaural label and no owned_overrides binaural_pairs entry
REPORT	Identity	Duplicate client record: sweep/jenn-doyle.html ('Bowls for Jenn', set -30..+45) lists the same one-of-a-kind 8" E+45 Apophyllite, Lemon Aura Gold as owned — almost certainly the same person split across two records (like the Sharda/Shardae merge); needs merging
REPORT	Collisions	The G row and minis/forks/pyramid cards also appear on Annie Bessette's, Anne Ortlepp's and Victoria DeRoche's drafts — by design (first come, first served), tracked for SOLD-stamping
REPORT	B2	Pick lines 'an A mini practitioner bowl' / 'an F mini practitioner bowl' put a/an directly before a note name — adjectival use, borderline, judgment call for ML
REPORT	B16	H1 'Bowls for Jennifer' — missing last name (house rule; page predates Aug-7 rule, one-pass fix)

#12 Anne Ortlepp

$19,386 lifetime · cash-urgent

8 FAIL2 EXCEPTION?8 REPORT

Open Anne’s page →

Set analysis — PASS
Page claims: No set-level chord (3 bowls); rec headings claim: 'C# (completes a minor chord with your F and A#)', 'D (completes a major chord with your F and A#)', 'C (C is the perfect 5th of your F)'
Recomputed: Owned {E, F, A#} form no triad, no maj6/7, no min7, no pentatonic (>=4 of 5) — correct to claim none. C#+F+A# = A# minor (A#, C#, F) correct; D+F+A# = A# major (A#, D, F) correct; C above F is a perfect fifth, direction correct

FAIL	A2	12" E+25 Aqua Aura Gold +10 past her +15 edge (band <=10), beyond the 5c buffer, under 'A deeper E' with NO by-ear/listen line — Rules 10b/check_window require one for the deep-bowl exception, and it is not a SuperGrade
FAIL	A3	12" D0 Laughing Buddha, Frosted Rim Inside Card shows '4th octave'; live Shopify tag is 3rd octave
FAIL	A3	5" A#-20 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner, Platinum Card octave blank; live tag is 5th octave (stale cache)
FAIL	A5	7" C#-15 Indigo, Platinum Practitioner ARCHIVED live but still a linked, Special-price card with no Sold mark (unsent page — FIX-THEN-PUBLISH per R2)
FAIL	A5	9" C+5 Tesseract Salt, Platinum ARCHIVED live; still linked and badged, no Sold mark (unsent — fix-then-publish)
FAIL	A5	7" D+15 Larimar Tall ARCHIVED live; still a linked card, no Sold mark (unsent — fix-then-publish)
FAIL	A5	5" F+5 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner, Tibetan Quartz Copper Aura ARCHIVED live; still linked and badged, no Sold mark (unsent — fix-then-publish)
FAIL	Sections (R6)	'Mini practitioner bowls, tuning forks, and pyramids' section holds 3 minis but NO tuning fork and NO pyramid (the live 12" E+30 Violet Flame fork is in her note E and runs on sibling drafts), and there is no SuperGrades section — R6 requires all four
EXCEPTION?	A6	Unbadged >=?$5k bowls eligible under price_5k but Apr-25 consignment (E5 conflict): 12" C-15 White Alchemy Gold, Palladium (Inside) $5,939; 12" E-10 Rose Quartz, White Light Angel Gold, Frosted (Inside) $5,813; 6" D+10 Egyptian Blue, Platinum w/Gold Divine Flower of Life $7,392 — ML to rule
EXCEPTION?	B11	'C (C is the perfect 5th of your F)' — bare interval name, unexplained, to a client with no recorded music background; E4 lanes interval wording as EXCEPTION? not FAIL; direction is correct (also restates C twice in one heading — B12 nit)
REPORT	A2	Band <=5 buffer bowls with only the >20c span line, no plain by-ear line (Rules 7): 8" C#+15... wait C#+15 is in range; the +20s: 8" C#+15 in range, 9" C#+20 Larimar, 12" C#+20 Dead Sea Salt, 10" D+20 Celestite, 10" C+20 Lemon Angel Gold (5 past +15) and 9" D-30 Moldavite, Palladium (5 past -25) — E1 says band for one-pass re-laning
REPORT	A3	10" D0 Moldavite untagged live (blank shown correctly — ask ML). Owned 8" E-25 shows 4th octave and matches live; owned 12" F+15 Dead Sea Salt and 6" A#-5 Apophyllite show no octave and their archived products are untagged — ask ML (Rules 11a)
REPORT	A4	Zero-cent cards render '12" D+0' / '10" D+0' where titles read 'D0'; the 5" E+10 double practitioner size line drops the 4" B+10 half of the title
REPORT	A6	Offer copy has no expiry while the discount runs (R5)
REPORT	Alchemy dup	Rec 12" C#+20 Dead Sea Salt shares the Dead Sea Salt alchemy with her owned 12" F+15 Dead Sea Salt, Violet Flame Aura, Transcendent, and rec 6" D+10 Egyptian Blue, Platinum echoes her owned 8" E-25 Egyptian Blue, Platinum Practitioner — partial matches vs 'never offer an alchemy the client already owns'; judgment to ML
REPORT	B2	Pick lines 'an A# mini practitioner bowl' / 'an F mini practitioner bowl' — a/an directly before a note name, adjectival, borderline
REPORT	B16	H1 'Bowls for Anne' — missing last name; note this is Anne ORTLEPP, not covered by the Anne Aurigue D5 grandfather
REPORT	Collisions	C#/D rows and minis shared with Annie Bessette's and Jennifer Doyle's drafts (by design; first come, first served)

Music check — UPHELD

Owned: E-25, F+15, A#-5; stated -25 to +15 matches. C#+F+A# = A# minor (A#-C#-F, 3+4 semitones, F standing for E# under sharp-only naming); D+F+A# = A# major (A#-D-F, 4+3 — the sharp-only spelling of the triad); C is the perfect 5th of F (7 semitones). Deeper-E entries (12" E-10 and E+25, 3rd octave) genuinely sit below her 4th-octave E-25. Minis all use owned notes (A#, E, F), and the binaural line's referent is the genuine 5" E+10 Double Practitioner binaural product.

Music check — UPHELD

Owned: E-25, F+15, A#-5 (matches bowls_master; no overrides). '-25 to +15' correct. No triad or pentatonic possible in {E, F, A#} (semitone E-F kills pentatonic membership; no major/minor triad contains all-of-any-pair plus a third owned note), so the plain 'Your set' heading is right. C# completes A# minor (A#, C#, F) with owned F+A#: correct. D completes A# major (A#, D, F) with owned F+A#: correct (A#->D major 3rd, D->F minor 3rd). C = perfect 5th of F (7 semitones up): correct and direction-correct. 'A deeper E' cards (12" E-10, 12" E+25) are both tagged 3rd octave vs her owned 8" E-25 tagged 4th on the page: genuinely deeper. Minis all in owned notes (A#, E, F) and the binaural pick sits on an actual Double Practitioner product. Span lines true (45/50/35/35). Note for the window auditor, not a musical-claim failure: the deeper-E section's 'in your tuning' line covers E+25 against a -25..+15 set (10c past the edge; deep-bowl/by-ear lane per Rules 10b).

Voice

FAIL	C (C is the perfect 5th of your F) R4 — bare "perfect 5th" with no explanation/attribution (direction correct: F up to C is a perfect 5th). Rules.md 17c sanctions the naming, but R4 supersedes: must be explained in a human way.
REPORT	4th octave See other C (C is the perfect 5th of your F) options (3) B12-adjacent, template-wide — the "See other … options (N)" toggle restates the entire section heading verbatim, producing garbled strings like "See other A deeper G# options (14)" (erin-forsyth) and "See other D# (completes a major chord with your F# and B) options (12)" (candice-sutnick). One template fix.

#13 Annie Bessette

$19,114 lifetime · cash-urgent

8 FAIL4 EXCEPTION?6 REPORT

Open Annie’s page →

Set analysis — PASS
Page claims: 'Your set is -30 to -5. Your bowls make a B minor chord: B, D, F#.' Scale section: full B natural minor = B, C#, D, E, F#, G, A; recs add 'the 2nd' (C#), 'the 4th' (E), 'the minor 6th' (G), 'the minor 7th' (A)
Recomputed: Owned {D, F#, B} = B minor (B, D, F#) — exact, only triad the notes form; B natural minor spelled correctly; missing scale notes are exactly C#, E, G, A and all four are offered; degrees direction-correct (C#=2nd, E=4th, G=minor 6th, A=minor 7th above B)

FAIL	A2	8" E+5 Aqua Aura Gold +10 past her -5 edge (band <=10), beyond the 5c buffer, no by-ear line — and it is the badged front-row pick of the E section
FAIL	A2	9" C#+5 Mt. Shasta Serpentine, Sedona Red Rock White Light Angel Gold +10 past the -5 edge (band <=10), no by-ear line
FAIL	A2	6" C#-40 Itoigawa Jade, White Light Angel Gold Frosted Rim 10 past the -30 edge (band <=10), 5th octave (not deep), no by-ear line
FAIL	A2	6" A-40 Celestite 10 past the -30 edge (band <=10), no by-ear line
FAIL	A3	10" G-25 Mt. Shasta Serpentine, Sedona Red Rock, White Light Angel Gold Card shows '4th octave'; live Shopify tag is 3rd octave
FAIL	A5	7" C#-15 Indigo, Platinum Practitioner ARCHIVED live but still a linked, Special-price card with no Sold mark (unsent page — FIX-THEN-PUBLISH per R2)
FAIL	Sections (R6)	The combined section holds a single mini double practitioner — no tuning forks, no pyramids; and there is no SuperGrades section (R6 requires all four on every proposal)
FAIL	B7	Semicolon in client copy: 'Your minor chord (B, D, F#) is the heart of it; these add the 2nd and the 4th...' — semicolons are banned marks
EXCEPTION?	A2	7" A-40 Grandfather Morph, Practitioner 10c out of window but a practitioner bowl — window treatment for practitioner/mini bowls is OPEN per R6/E6, route to ML
EXCEPTION?	A2	5" F#0, 5" E+15 Mini Supergrade Double Practitioner, Violet Flame Aura Binaural F#0 is 5c past the -5 edge and the E+15 side is 20c past — mini practitioner, OPEN per R6/E6
EXCEPTION?	A6	Unbadged Divine/>= $5k bowls, all Apr-25 consignment (E5 conflict): 7" G-5 Divine Blissful Transformation Tall $5,004; 7" G-35 Platinum w/Gold Etched Ring Of Light Practitioner $6,211; 12" A-5 Indian Pipestone, Palladium (Inside) $6,104; 12" A-25 St. Germain Sky $5,499; 12" E-10 Rose Quartz, WLAG, Frosted (Inside) $5,813 — ML to rule
EXCEPTION?	B11	Degree wording 'the 2nd / the 4th / the minor 6th / the minor 7th' in intro and all four headings — allowed by Rules 17c, contradicted by the newer plain-spoken memory; E4 lanes it EXCEPTION? per client sophistication; all degrees direction-correct
REPORT	A2	Band <=5 buffer bowls with only the span line, no by-ear line: 9" E0 Citrine, 8" E0 Great Salt Lake Salt Pink Aura Gold, 7" G0 Carnelian WLAG, 6" A0 Pink Himalayan Salt (5 over), 7" G-35 Great Salt Lake Salt Grandmother, 7" G-35 Platinum Ring Of Light Practitioner, 6" A-35 Azeztulite (5 under)
REPORT	A3	Owned 3 cards show no octave; the archived owned products carry no octave tags live — ask ML (Rules 11a). All other displayed octaves match live tags (incl. 3rd-octave 10" A-30, 9" A-5, 8" A-10, 12" A-5, 12" A-25 — under a plain note heading, not a 'deeper' heading, so no Rules 4a issue)
REPORT	A4	Zero-cent cards render '+0' (9" E+0, 8" E+0, 7" G+0, 6" A+0, 5" F#+0) where titles read 'E0' etc.; the double practitioner size line drops its 5" E+15 half
REPORT	A6	Offer copy has no expiry while the discount runs (R5)
REPORT	B16	H1 'Bowls for Annie' — missing last name
REPORT	Collisions	C# row, G row and the 12" E-10 shared with Anne Ortlepp's and Jennifer Doyle's drafts (by design)

Music check — UPHELD

Owned: D-30, F#-15, B-5; B+D+F# = B minor triad (3+4 semitones) and the stated -30 to -5 range matches. 'The full B natural minor scale, in order, is B, C#, D, E, F#, G, A' is correct, and every degree heading recomputes from B: C# = 2nd (2 semitones), E = 4th (5), G = minor 6th (8), A = minor 7th (10) — exactly the notes that fill B,D,F# out to the seven-note scale. The single mini (5" F#+0 Double Practitioner, Violet Flame Aura Binaural) is a genuine binaural double product on an owned note, so the doubles-are-binaural line holds.

Music check — UPHELD

Owned: D-30, F#-15, B-5 (matches bowls_master). '-30 to -5' correct. B minor chord (B, D, F#) is the exact triad — B->D minor 3rd, D->F# major 3rd; it is not any other complete major/minor triad (relative D major would need A). B natural minor spelled correctly as B, C#, D, E, F#, G, A. Degrees all correct: C# 2nd (2 semitones), E 4th (5), G minor 6th (8), A minor 7th (10); with owned 1-3-5 they complete the seven-note scale as claimed. All four 'span more than 20 cents' lines true (45/35/35/40, also circularly). The single minis item is a genuine Mini Supergrade Double Practitioner (F#, an owned note) with the 'binaural' pick — the 'doubles are binaural' line has a true referent. Nothing to refute.

Voice

FAIL	Your minor chord (B, D, F#) is the heart of it; these add the 2nd and the 4th and the minor 6th and the minor 7th to fill out the scale R4 — unexplained interval/degree jargon stacked four deep with no human explanation or attribution (Aileen's degree wording was grandfathered, NOT a precedent). Section heads repeat it bare: "C# (the 2nd)", "E (the 4th)", "G (the minor 6th)", "A (the minor 7th)".
FAIL	is the heart of it; these add the 2nd B7 — semicolon in copy. Hand/template sentence, not in client_page.py, so no engine-default cover. Same sentence carries the R4 hit; one rewrite fixes both.

#14 Kate Hansen

$19,093 lifetime

10 FAIL1 EXCEPTION?7 REPORT

Open Kate’s page →

Set analysis — PASS
Page claims: 'Your set is -40 to -15. Your bowls form a C major pentatonic: C, D, E, G, A. That is the open, no-wrong-notes core of C major.' Scale section: full C major = C, D, E, F, G, A, B; recs add 'the 4th' (F) and 'the major 7th' (B)
Recomputed: Owned {C, D, E, G, A} = complete C major pentatonic (C, D, E, G, A) — exact (relative A minor pentatonic); set also already holds C major (C, E, G), A minor (A, C, E), C major 6 (C, E, G, A), A minor 7 (A, C, E, G); missing full-scale notes are exactly F and B, both offered, degrees direction-correct

FAIL	A2	10" F-5 Platinum, Frosted Rim Inside +10 past her -15 edge (band <=10), beyond the 5c buffer, no by-ear line — badged front-row pick
FAIL	A2	8" F-5 Rose Quartz, White Light Aura Gold +10 past the -15 edge (band <=10), no by-ear line
FAIL	A2	9" F-50 (E+50) Rose Quartz 10 past the -40 edge (band <=10), no by-ear line
FAIL	A2	7" F-50 (E+50) Monroe-Utah Hot Springs, Platinum Frosted Base, Limited Edition Water Element w/Etched Tesseract (Inside) 10 past the -40 edge (band <=10), no by-ear line
FAIL	A2	6" B-50 (A#+50) Carnelian, White Light Aura Gold 10 past the -40 edge (band <=10), 5th octave (high, not deep), no by-ear line
FAIL	A5	9" F-10 Sacred Feminine Kudaka Island Salt, Pink Aura Gold ARCHIVED live but still a linked card, no Sold mark (unsent page — FIX-THEN-PUBLISH per R2)
FAIL	A5	6" F-10 Aqua Aura Gold ARCHIVED live; still a linked card, no Sold mark (unsent — fix-then-publish)
FAIL	Sections (R6)	NO mini practitioner/tuning forks/pyramids section at all (Rules 18d — the exact omission ML flagged on Khor) and no SuperGrades section
FAIL	Alchemy dup	7" B-45 Black Tourmaline Recommends the alchemy she already owns (8" G-15 Black Tourmaline, Frosted (Inside)) — 'never offer a note OR alchemy the client already owns' with no recorded ML override
FAIL	B7	Semicolon in client copy: 'You have the pentatonic core (C, D, E, G, A); these add the 4th and the major 7th...' — banned mark
EXCEPTION?	B11	Degree wording 'the 4th' / 'the major 7th' — E4 lane, direction-correct in C major
REPORT	A2	Band <=5 buffer bowls with only the span line: 7" F-10 Amethyst WLAG Tall (badged), 6" F-10 Aqua Aura Gold, 9" F-10 Sacred Feminine Kudaka Island Salt, 10" F-10 Ruby WLAG Frosted (3rd-octave deep — deep exception would also need a by-ear line), 8" F-45 Dead Sea Salt Aqua Aura Gold, 7" F-45 Apophyllite Smokey Quartz, 7" B-45 Black Tourmaline
REPORT	A3	6" F-20 Apophyllite, Archangel Michael, Androgynous Indium (Inside) untagged live (blank shown correctly — ask ML); owned 7 cards show no octave and their archived products are untagged (ask ML). All other displayed octaves match live tags
REPORT	A4	7" B-45 Black Tourmaline Live tag says '-30 while the title says B-45 — tag/title cents conflict, heads-up for ML (title is truth, card follows title)
REPORT	A6	Offer copy has no expiry while the discount runs (R5)
REPORT	Binaural	Two C-20s (10" Moldavite + 6" Mother Of Platinum Frosted) are a same-note pair = likely intentional binaural (Rules 8) but unlabeled and not in owned_overrides
REPORT	B1	'the open, no-wrong-notes core of C major' names C major without notes in that sentence (the full scale is spelled in the next section) — borderline vs Rules 0, judgment
REPORT	B16	H1 'Bowls for Kate' — missing last name

Music check — UPHELD

Owned: C-20, C-20, D-30, E-15, G-40, G-15, A-20 — distinct notes C, D, E, G, A form exactly a C major pentatonic, and the stated -40 to -15 range matches (min G-40, max E-15/G-15). The full C major listing and the F = 4th / B = major 7th degree names are correct as the two notes missing from the pentatonic. No binaural or minis claims on the page (the missing minis section is a checklist R6 matter outside this musical pass). The 6" B-50 shown as (A#+50) and the two F-50 shown as (E+50) are identical pitches by circular cents, transparently double-labeled toward her negative tuning.

Music check — UPHELD

Owned: C-20, C-20, D-30, E-15, G-40, G-15, A-20 (matches bowls_master; the two case rows in the CSV are packing cases, not bowls). '-40 to -15' correct. Pitch classes {C, D, E, G, A} = C major pentatonic exactly (5/5; no other major pentatonic matches better), so the headline claim recomputes; C major scale spelled correctly and F = the 4th, B = the major 7th both correct. The two C-20s (10" and 6") are a same-note pair — intentional binaural per Rules 8, and the page claims nothing about them; the two Gs are 25 cents apart with no claim attached. Enharmonic cross-labels verified circularly: 9" F-50 (E+50), 7" F-50 (E+50), 6" B-50 (A#+50). Both span lines true (F section 45, B section 30, circularly likewise). Out of my lane but noting: no deeper-octave and no minis/forks/pyramids section (R6 required-section issue), and no binaural boilerplate appears, so no vacuous claim either. All musical claims survive.

Voice

FAIL	You have the pentatonic core (C, D, E, G, A); these add the 4th and the major 7th, opening it into the full scale R4 — unexplained degree jargon; headings "F (the 4th)", "B (the major 7th)".
FAIL	(C, D, E, G, A); these add B7 — semicolon in copy (same template sentence).

#15 Victoria DeRoche

$18,460 lifetime · cash-urgent

2 FAIL1 EXCEPTION?7 REPORT

Open Victoria’s page →

Set analysis — FAIL
Page claims: None — 'Your set is +20 to +45' (cents only); no chord or scale named anywhere
Recomputed: Owned {C, D, E, G, A} + F (other-list 10" F+20) = complete C major pentatonic (C, D, E, G, A), the same five notes as an A minor pentatonic, with the F extending toward full C major; the set also already forms C major (C, E, G), F major (F, A, C), A minor (A, C, E), D minor (D, F, A), C major 6 (C, E, G, A), F major 7 (F, A, C, E), D minor 7 (D, F, A, C), A minor 7 (A, C, E, G). Only B is missing from the full C major scale

FAIL	A1	Rules.md 1 / A1: misses an exact match — her bowls form a complete C major pentatonic (C, D, E, G, A) and the page names nothing (Kate Hansen's draft names the identical structure)
FAIL	Sections (R6)	No pyramid item in the combined section and no SuperGrades section (minis and forks present) — R6 requires all four
EXCEPTION?	A2	5" E+10, 4" B+10 Mini Supergrade Double Practitioner, Tibetan Quartz Copper, Aqua Aura Gold E+10 is 10c below her +20 edge — out-of-window mini practitioner, OPEN per R6/E6, route to ML
REPORT	A3	12" C+40 Sage Aura Gold Tuning Fork untagged live (blank shown correctly — ask ML); owned 6 cards + other-list bowl show no octave, archived owned products untagged live (Rules 11a — ask ML). Displayed octaves on the other 3 rec cards match live tags
REPORT	A6	Offer copy has no expiry while the discount runs (R5)
REPORT	Recs coverage	Page carries NO 'bowls that pair' section at all. Only B is missing from her full C major scale, and B completes G major (G, B, D) with her owned G and D — but every in-stock B (10" B-40/-25/-20, 7" B-45, 6" B-50) is negative-tuned against her +20..+45 window, which likely emptied the section. Route to ML: offer a by-ear/deeper B, or confirm none
REPORT	Coverage	'Cover the range' for minis/forks: her F (+20) had a matching 5" F+5 mini that ran on sibling drafts (now sold/ARCHIVED anyway), and the catalog's 4" G0/G+20 double mini has its G+20 side at her exact edge — worth ML's eye
REPORT	B2	Pick lines 'an A mini practitioner bowl' / 'an E tuning fork' / 'a C tuning fork' — a/an directly before a note name, adjectival, borderline
REPORT	B16	H1 'Bowls for Victoria' — missing last name
REPORT	Collisions	All 4 rec cards also appear on Jennifer Doyle's and/or Anne Ortlepp's drafts (by design; first come, first served — tracked for SOLD-stamping)

#16 Tricia Morfin

$22,591 lifetime · cash-urgent

2 FAIL6 REPORT

Open Tricia’s page →

Set analysis — PASS
Page claims: No chord/scale claimed; page says only "Your set is +35 to +45" under h2 "Your set"
Recomputed: Owned notes C#+35, D+40, D#+40, A+40, A#+45 form no major/minor triad, no maj6/maj7/min7, and no >=4-note major pentatonic, so no claim is correct; range +35 to +45 matches; rec headings verified (F# completes F# minor with her C#+A; F completes A# minor with her C#+A#; G completes G minor with her D+A#)

FAIL	A5 active/unsold (live Shopify)	12" F#+45 Smokey Quartz, Crystal Tones Alchemy Singing Bowl ARCHIVED live (inventory 0) but still a live, linked, badged rec card with no SOLD mark; Rules 14a. Unsent draft, so R2 lane = fix-then-publish (rebuild before sending), not blocked.
FAIL	R6 required sections	No SuperGrades / deeper-octaves section anywhere on the page (R6 + Rules 4b, established 5-bowl collector); the minis/forks/pyramids section exists but the SuperGrade section is absent entirely.
REPORT	A2 near-boundary band	Four bowls sit exactly at the 20c pairwise limit (10 past the owned range under the Rules.md-7 reading, section E1): 7" F#+25 Earth, White Light Angel Gold; 12" F+25 Ocean Gold Frosted Rim; 12" G+25 Rose Quartz, Palladium; 7" G+25 Laughing Buddha Supreme Practitioner (practitioner = EXCEPTION? per R6/E6 if ML re-lanes the window).
REPORT	A3 octave tags (live)	Untagged products correctly shown blank, need ML tags: 8" F#+45 Great Salt Lake Salt, 7" F#+30 Laughing Buddha Supreme Platinum (Inside) Practitioner, 7" G+40 Laughing Buddha Practitioner, 10" D#+30 Grandmother Pyramid.
REPORT	A3 owned octave display (Rules 11a)	Owned cards for 8" D+40 Rose Quartz Platinum, 8" D#+40 Divine Kryon, 6" A+40 Mt. Shasta Serpentine WLAG, 6" A#+45 Palladium Charcoal show no octave (only the 9" C#+35 does); archived products likely untagged, ask ML.
REPORT	A6 offer expiry (R5)	Offer copy is open-ended ("on loan that are going back soon", no `until` deadline) while the discount runs; ML wants time limits, mechanism exists in client_page.py.
REPORT	B16 H1 full name	H1 is "Bowls for Tricia", missing last name (post-Aug-7 house rule).
REPORT	audit-integrity	During this audit the scratch query files (/tmp/handles.json, /tmp/q0.txt, /tmp/q1.txt) were overwritten mid-run with a different product list; ignored, all live lookups were re-derived from the page HTML and verified (170/170 handles match the pages).

Music check — UPHELD

Owned: C#+35, D+40, D#+40, A+40, A#+45; stated +35 to +45 matches. F#+C#+A = F# minor (F#-A-C#, 3+4); F+C#+A# = A# minor (A#-C#-F, F standing for E# under sharp-only naming, 3+4); G+D+A# = G minor (G-A#-D, 3+4). Mini notes D#, A#, A are all owned. The binaural boilerplate sentence has no referent here (D# pyramid, A# pyramid, A mini — no repeated note, no double product), so it asserts nothing false about any pair; noted as inert engine boilerplate, not a musical falsehood. The 10" G+50 shown as (G#-50) is the identical pitch by circular cents, transparently double-labeled, and functions as the G of her +35..+45 tuning.

Music check — UPHELD

Owned: C#+35, D+40, D#+40, A+40, A#+45 (matches bowls_master). '+35 to +45' correct. No exact triad exists (checked all 24 major/minor roots), no major 6/maj7/m7 4-note chord is complete, and no major pentatonic reaches 4/5 (max 3), so the plain 'Your set' heading is right. F# completes F# minor (F#, A, C#) with owned C#+A: correct. F completes A# minor (A#, C#, F) with owned C#+A#: correct (A#->C# minor 3rd, C#->F major 3rd; sharp-name spelling of E# as F is house-correct). G completes G minor (G, A#, D) with owned D+A#: correct. Span lines correct: F# and F sections span exactly 20 (line rightly absent), G section spans 25 including the G+50 (=G#-50) card (line rightly present). Minor note: the boilerplate 'The doubles are binaural...' sentence has no referent here (minis are one D# pyramid, one A# pyramid, one A mini — three distinct notes, no double products); vacuous filler that asserts nothing false about any actual bowl, flagged for ML as dead copy but not a false musical claim.

#17 Melissa Birnbeck

$22,322 lifetime

4 FAIL1 EXCEPTION?4 REPORT

Open Melissa’s page →

Set analysis — PASS
Page claims: "Your E minor chord" / "Your bowls make an E minor chord: E, G, B"; set -45 to -30
Recomputed: Owned 10" B-45 Kunzite, 9" B-40 Carnelian Palladium Inside, 8" E-45 Turquoise Platinum, 12" G-30 Violet Flame Aura = notes E, G, B -> E minor (E, G, B) is the only triad; no maj6/7, min7 or pentatonic; scale additions correct (E natural minor: F#=2nd, A=4th, C=minor 6th, D=minor 7th); range -45 to -30 matches

FAIL	A5 active/unsold (live Shopify)	9" D-40 Platinum, Grandmother (Base), Crystal Tones Alchemy Singing Bowl ARCHIVED live (inventory 0) but still a live, linked, Special-badged rec with no SOLD mark; unsent draft -> R2 fix-then-publish (rebuild before sending).
FAIL	R6 required sections	The entire "Mini practitioner bowls, tuning forks, and pyramids" section is missing (Rules 18d: do not skip); a qualifying live fork exists in her own E note, 12" E+30 Violet Flame Aura Tuning Fork (forks are window-exempt).
FAIL	R6 required sections	No SuperGrades / deeper-octaves section (R6 + Rules 4b); 14" F#-45 SuperGrade Aqua Aura Gold sits exactly in her -45..-30 tuning on her scale's 2nd (F#) and is absent.
FAIL	B7 banned marks	Semicolon in client copy: "Your minor chord (E, G, B) is the heart of it; these add the 2nd..." (engine scale-completion boilerplate, also on Judy and Victoria).
EXCEPTION?	B11 interval/degree wording	Section heads use degree names ("the 2nd", "the 4th", "the minor 6th", "the minor 7th") - E4 conflict (files allow, plain-spoken memory bans); direction-correct; lane per client sophistication, ML to rule.
REPORT	A2 tuning window (R1)	6" F#-20 Rhodochrosite Crystal Tones Alchemy Singing Bowl Over the 20c pairwise band by 5 (25 from her B-45); band <=5 -> near-boundary judgment per R1, not auto-FAIL; F# section carries the span note but no plain by-ear line. All other recs incl. F#-50/A-50/D-50 land exactly at 20 and are in.
REPORT	A3 octave tags (live)	Untagged recs correctly blank (6" A-50 (G#+50) Apophyllite Androgynous Indium Platinum (Inside); 8" D-50 (C#+50) Egyptian Blue White Light Angel Gold); owned 8" E-45 Turquoise Platinum and 12" G-30 Violet Flame Aura cards missing octave (Rules 11a) - ask ML.
REPORT	owned order (Rules 13)	Shown B-45, B-40, E-45, G-30; if the untagged 12" G-30 is 3rd octave it belongs before the two 3rd-octave Bs (G sorts before B) - unverifiable until the octave is tagged.
REPORT	B16 H1 full name	H1 "Bowls for Melissa", missing last name.

Music check — UPHELD

Owned: B-45, B-40, E-45, G-30; E+G+B is an E minor triad (3+4 semitones) and the stated -45 to -30 range matches. 'The full E natural minor scale, in order, is E, F#, G, A, B, C, D' is correct, and the degree headings recompute exactly: F# = 2nd (2 semitones from E), A = 4th (5), C = minor 6th (8), D = minor 7th (10) — precisely the four notes missing from E,G,B to complete the scale, all in-key. The two owned B bowls carry no binaural claim (and two same-note bowls are a sanctioned non-error regardless). The F#-50 recommendations shown as (F+50) are the same pitch by circular cents and sit consistent with her -45..-30 tuning.

Music check — UPHELD

Owned: B-45 (3rd oct), B-40 (3rd oct), E-45, G-30 (matches bowls_master; the two inventory_tab rows confirm 3rd octave for both B bowls). '-45 to -30' correct. E minor chord (E, G, B) is the exact and only triad in the set — relative G major (G, B, D) would need D, not owned. E natural minor spelled correctly as E, F#, G, A, B, C, D (2-1-2-2-1-2-2). Degrees all correct: F# 2nd (2 semitones), A 4th (5), C minor 6th (8), D minor 7th (10), and together they complete the scale as claimed. The two B bowls (-45/-40, 5 cents apart, same octave, adjacent) are an intentional binaural pair per Rules 8 and the page makes no claim about them. Enharmonic cross-labels all verified circularly: 12" F#-50 (F+50), 8" F#-50 (F+50), 6" A-50 (G#+50), 8" D-50 (C#+50). Span lines true (30/25/25; C section span 5 rightly has no line). Out of my lane but noting: the page has no minis/forks/pyramids section (R6 required-section issue for the sections auditor).

Voice

FAIL	Your minor chord (E, G, B) is the heart of it; these add the 2nd and the 4th and the minor 6th and the minor 7th to fill out the scale R4 — same unexplained-degree template as Annie Bessette. Bare degree headings: "F# (the 2nd)", "A (the 4th)", "C (the minor 6th)", "D (the minor 7th)".
FAIL	is the heart of it; these add the 2nd B7 — semicolon in copy (same template sentence).
REPORT	Your E minor chord ... Your bowls make an E minor chord: E, G, B. B1 letter — chord/scale names in H2s run bare with the notes supplied in the next line after a colon ("in order, is E, F#, G, A, B, C, D") rather than in parentheses after the name. Notes ARE present, so laning as judgment for ML, not FAIL. Same pattern on annie-bessette, merisa-horgan ("Your C major scale"), judy-yamamura, kate-hansen, victoria-wooding.

#18 Judy Yamamura

$21,912 lifetime · cash-urgent

9 FAIL1 EXCEPTION?6 REPORT

Open Judy’s page →

Set analysis — FAIL
Page claims: "Your B major pentatonic" - "Your bowls form a B major pentatonic: B, C#, D#, F#, G#"; set -40 to +15
Recomputed: Recomputed from ALL records (4 from-us bowls PLUS ~25 client-list bowls in bowls_master.csv that the page drops): pitch classes cover 11 of 12 notes (only A# absent), giving complete major pentatonics (C major pent complete: C, D, E, G, A) and 9 major / 9 minor triads; her true cent range is -50 to +20, not -40 to +15. The B-major-pentatonic claim is computed from an incomplete set

FAIL	A1 owned-set completeness	~24 client-list bowls omitted: "Other bowls in your collection" shows only the 6" G#+15 Lemurian Seed Sage Aura Gold, while bowls_master client_tab records e.g. 10 inch Abalone C#-50, 9 inch Diamond White Light Aura Gold C#-40, 8 inch Carnelian Smoky Quartz E-20, 10 inch Sedona Red Rock F-20, 9 inch Citrine Palladium A-5, 10 inch Grandmother B0, 12 inch Charcoal D+10, 8 inch Divine Grandmother D+20 and more; Rules 13 requires the whole collection.
FAIL	A1 duplicate-note rec	Page recommends E ("the 4th") but her client list includes an owned E (8 inch Carnelian Smoky Quartz E-20); never offer a note the client already owns - consequence of the dropped bowls.
FAIL	A4/A7 non-bowl products as bowls	8 jewelry finger rings presented as bowls in the E section with sizes/cents fabricated from ring model numbers: 13" E+9 Moldavite Ring M13 Size 9, 10" E+9 Moldavite Ring M10 Size 9, 9" E+8 Moldavite Ring M9 Size 8.5, 8" E+8 Moldavite Ring M8 Size 8.75, 7" E+8 Amber Ring A7 Size 8, 6" E+9 Moldavite Ring M6 Size 9, 4" E+10 Amazonite Ring A4 Size 10, 4" E+8 Moldavite Ring M4 Size 8 - live titles/tags say Jewelry/rings ($33-$454), photos are rings.
FAIL	A6 special badges	Moldavite Ring M13, Size 9 Special price badge on a $196 jewelry ring: not an unpaid-batch row, not Divine-titled, not >=$5,000.
FAIL	A5 active/unsold (live Shopify)	12" D#+10 (measures +20) White Light Aura Gold, Crystal Tones Alchemy Singing Bowl ARCHIVED live (inventory 0) but live-linked and Special-badged with no SOLD mark; unsent draft -> R2 fix-then-publish.
FAIL	A2 tuning window (R1)	Owned set spans 45c as shown (-40..+15; truly -50..+20 with the dropped bowls) - a scattered set per R1 must be built around a core with outliers as stand-alones, but the page treats the whole spread as one window. Bands vs the shown range: over by <=10: 7" E-50 (D#+50) Pink Ocean Gold Practitioner (EXCEPTION? practitioner), 12" E+25 Aqua Aura Gold, 12" F#-50 (F+50) Great Salt Lake Salt; over by <=5: 8" E-45 Grandmother, 7" E-45 Citrine Platinum, 9" E-45 GSLS Green Aura Gold, 9" E+20 Moldavite, 7" A#-45 Apophyllite GHAG, 10" A#-45 Mother Of Platinum, 12" A#-45 Grandfather Frosted Inside, 7" A#+20 Apophyllite LAG, 14" F#-45 SuperGrade AAG (2nd octave), 12" D#+10 (measures +20). Deep-SG sections carry only the span note, not the required listen/by-ear line (Rules 10b), so the deep exemption does not attach.
FAIL	A3 octave tags (live)	10" A#-15 Lemon Angel Gold Bowl Card says 4th octave; live Shopify tag is 3rd octave.
FAIL	A3 octave tags (live)	5" A#-20 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner Bowl, Platinum Card octave blank but live tag 5th octave exists (missing display when a tag exists).
FAIL	B7 banned marks	Semicolon in scale copy: "You have the pentatonic core (B, C#, D#, F#, G#); these add the 4th..."
EXCEPTION?	B11 interval/degree wording	"the 4th", "the major 7th", "pentatonic" used - E4 conflict, lane to ML per client sophistication.
REPORT	A3 octave tags (live)	10" A#-45 Mother Of Platinum Bowl Live product carries BOTH 3rd octave and 4th octave tags; card shows 3rd - heads up, ask ML which is right.
REPORT	A4 tag/title conflicts	9" E+20 Moldavite (handle 9-c-35-moldavite..., live cents tag '-35 vs title E+20) and 7" A#+20 Apophyllite Lemon Aura Gold (tag '+15 vs title +20): cards follow the titles, correct per 11d, but the tags contradict - flag to ML.
REPORT	A4 raw client text	The one Other-bowls line renders her raw list text as the label: "6 inchG#+15Lemurian Seed Sage Aura Gold" (unspaced, note+cents embedded) instead of a cleaned name.
REPORT	A3 owned octave display (Rules 11a)	Owned 12" B-5 Moldavite, Palladium card missing octave; untagged rec 8" E+10 Dead Sea Salt Aqua Aura Gold correctly blank (no live octave tag) - ask ML to tag.
REPORT	A6 offer expiry (R5)	Open-ended offer copy while the discount runs (no `until`).
REPORT	B16 H1 full name	H1 "Bowls for Judy", missing last name.

Voice

FAIL	You have the pentatonic core (B, C#, D#, F#, G#); these add the 4th and the major 7th, opening it into the full scale R4 — "the 4th and the major 7th" bare, no explanation/attribution; headings "E (the 4th)" and "A# (the major 7th)" repeat it. (The pentatonic itself IS explained — see PASS entry.)
FAIL	(B, C#, D#, F#, G#); these add B7 — semicolon in copy (same template sentence).
REPORT	6.0" G#+15 6 inchG#+15Lemurian Seed Sage Aura Gold Data glitch visible in client-facing copy (garbled duplicated name). Related glitches: melissa-helwig "Other bowls" rows "14.0\" C-40 144615 10\" C-40 Platinum", "13.0\" A-45 139359 7\" A-45 Moldavite, Platinum", "14.0\" A-30 145547 10\" A-30 Mother Of Platinum" (SKU + a second bowl's spec embedded); natalie-kimball owned card "Green Goddess, White Light Aura (Inside)-labeled G" on a D+45 row; erin-forsyth internal edit notes "(changed from +10)" / "(changed from -10)" shown to the client. Ask ML — not voice FAILs but they read wrong on a proposal.

#19 Amy Xiaoqin Ni

$21,017 lifetime · cash-urgent

7 FAIL2 EXCEPTION?4 REPORT

Open Amy’s page →

Set analysis — EXCEPTION?
Page claims: No chord/scale claimed; page says only "Your set is -15 to +40" under h2 "Your set"
Recomputed: Owned 10" D-15 Sacred Feminine Kudaka Island Salt, 7" A#+15 Rhodochrosite Palladium, 8" C#+40 Morganite Palladium, 10" G+40 Mt. Shasta Serpentine WLAG = notes D, A#, C#, G, which DO form an exact G minor chord (G, A#, D); no other triad, no pentatonic >=4. Page omits the G minor

FAIL	A4/A7 non-bowl products as bowls	Same 8 jewelry rings as Judy presented as bowls in the E section (13" E+9 Moldavite Ring M13 Size 9, 10" E+9 M10, 9" E+8 M9, 8" E+8 M8, 7" E+8 Amber Ring A7, 6" E+9 M6, 4" E+10 Amazonite Ring A4, 4" E+8 M4) - live tags Jewelry/rings, photos are finger rings, sizes fabricated from model numbers.
FAIL	A6 special badges	Moldavite Ring M13, Size 9 Special price badge on the $196 jewelry ring (not batch/Divine/>= $5k).
FAIL	A5 active/unsold (live Shopify)	Two live-linked recs are ARCHIVED (sold) with no SOLD mark: 9" F-10 Sacred Feminine Kudaka Island Salt, Pink Aura Gold Bowl and 6" F-10 Aqua Aura Gold Bowl; unsent draft -> R2 fix-then-publish.
FAIL	A2 tuning window (R1)	Owned set spans 55c (-15..+40) - scattered per R1, page treats it as one window with span notes instead of building around a core. Bands vs owned range: over by <=10: 8" E+50 (F-50) Frankincense WLAG, 8" F-25 Laughing Buddha Supreme WLAG (Inside), 9" E-25 Charcoal, 9" E-25 Itoigawa Jade; over by <=5: five F-20s, 8" F+45 Green Heart Ocean Gold, 7" F+45 Androgynous Indium, 7" E+45 Palladium Tall, 10" A#+45 Smokey Quartz, 9" A#+45 Grandmother Frosted, 8" E-20 Diamond, 6" A#+45 pyramid (exempt) and 5" A#-20 mini practitioner (EXCEPTION? per R6).
FAIL	A3 octave tags (live)	12" F+10 Tibetan Quartz Copper, Palladium Inside Card says 4th octave; live tag is 3rd octave (the known ML tag fix pending catalog re-pull, Status.md).
FAIL	A3 octave tags (live)	5" A#-20 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner Bowl, Platinum Card octave blank but live tag 5th octave exists.
FAIL	owned order (Rules 13)	Owned strip shows D-15, A#+15, C#+40, G+40; deepest-to-highest requires C# before D within an octave (and the 10" G+40 first if it is 3rd octave) - both C#+40 and G+40 cards also lack octave display (Rules 11a, REPORT: ask ML to tag).
EXCEPTION?	A1 chord claim	A1's letter makes a missed exact match a FAIL, but the G-minor bowls (G+40, A#+15, D-15) span 55 cents so naming the chord would present a set that cannot be played together - R1's scattered-set logic suggests the omission may be deliberate; ML to rule.
EXCEPTION?	B11 interval/degree wording	Heading "E (E is the minor 3rd of your C#)" uses interval wording - direction-correct (E is 3 semitones above C#); E4 conflict, ML to rule.
REPORT	A4 tag/title conflict	9" E+20 Moldavite Bowl Handle 9-c-35-moldavite... and live cents tag '-35 contradict the title E+20; card follows the title (correct), flag the tags to ML.
REPORT	A3 untagged recs	8" E+10 Dead Sea Salt Aqua Aura Gold and 6" F-20 Apophyllite Archangel Michael Androgynous Indium (Inside) have no live octave tag and are correctly blank - ask ML to tag.
REPORT	B16 H1 full name	H1 "Bowls for Amy", missing last name.
REPORT	cross-page collision	9" F-10 Sacred Feminine and 6" F-10 Aqua Aura Gold (both now sold) also appear on Victoria Wooding's page; shared-by-design, but both pages need the SOLD stamp in place.

Voice

FAIL

E (E is the minor 3rd of your C#)
R4 — bare "minor 3rd" with no explanation/attribution (direction correct: C# up to E). Also repeated in the toggle line "See other E (E is the minor 3rd of your C#) options (21)".

#20 Victoria Wooding

$20,139 lifetime · cash-urgent

5 FAIL1 EXCEPTION?4 REPORT

Open Victoria’s page →

Set analysis — PASS
Page claims: "Your C major pentatonic" - "Your bowls form a C major pentatonic: C, D, E, G, A"; set -5 to +10
Recomputed: Owned 10" A+10 Citrine (3rd oct), 9" C+5 Aqua Aura Gold WLAG Base, 9" D0 Platinum Grandmother (Base), 8" E0 Mt. Shasta Serpentine WLAG, 7" G-5 Tibetan Quartz Copper Platinum = C, D, E, G, A = complete C major pentatonic (same five notes as A minor pentatonic; also C major, A minor, C major 6, A minor 7 inside it); claim and range both match

FAIL	A5 active/unsold (live Shopify)	Three live-linked recs are ARCHIVED (sold) with no SOLD mark: 9" F-10 Sacred Feminine Kudaka Island Salt, Pink Aura Gold Bowl; 6" F-10 Aqua Aura Gold Bowl; 5" F+5 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner Bowl, Tibetan Quartz Copper Aura (half the minis section); unsent draft -> R2 fix-then-publish.
FAIL	A2 span/by-ear lines (Rules 9/10b)	"B (the major 7th)", "A deeper G" and "A deeper D" sections reach a combined span >20c (B+20s, G+20, 18" D-15) with NO span note and no by-ear line (the F section has one); the 18" D-15 Supergrade Androgynous Indium is a 2nd-octave SuperGrade whose deep exemption requires a listen-by-ear line that is absent.
FAIL	R6 forks coverage	Minis section has no tuning forks although two live forks sit in her OWN notes: 12" C+40 Sage Aura Gold Tuning Fork and 12" E+30 Violet Flame Aura Tuning Fork (forks are window-exempt; "cover the range, don't sample it"). No pyramids exist in her notes, so their absence is fine.
FAIL	A3 octave tags (live)	12" F+10 Tibetan Quartz Copper, Palladium Inside Card says 4th octave; live tag is 3rd octave (known pending tag re-pull).
FAIL	B7 banned marks	Semicolon in scale copy: "You have the pentatonic core (C, D, E, G, A); these add the 4th..."
EXCEPTION?	B11 interval/degree wording	"the 4th", "the major 7th", "pentatonic" used - E4 conflict, ML to rule.
REPORT	A2 near-boundary band	Eight recs over the 20c pairwise band by exactly 5 (<=5 band, judgment per R1): 9" F-15 Indigo Platinum and 9" F-15 Lemon Angel Gold (both featured + badged), 8" F+20 Palladium, 10" B+20 Black Tourmaline Frosted (Inside), 10" B+20 Great Salt Lake Salt Platinum, 6" B+20 Mt. Shasta Serpentine WLAG w/Etched Butterflies, 10" G+20 Morganite WLAG, 18" D-15 SuperGrade.
REPORT	A3 octave tags (live)	10" B+10 Platinum Card octave blank; the live octave tag is malformed ("3rd", not "3rd octave") so the engine could not read it - fix the tag.
REPORT	B16 H1 full name	H1 "Bowls for Victoria", missing last name.
REPORT	cross-page collision	The two sold F bowls (9" F-10 Sacred Feminine, 6" F-10 Aqua Aura Gold) are shared with Amy Xiaoqin Ni's page; per file rules both pages get SOLD stamped in place, never pulled.

Music check — REFUTED
Minis section: "Other forms in notes from your set, a different way to sound the same tones" includes a 5" F+5 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner.
Her owned notes are A+10, C+5, D0, E0, G-5 — the set contains no F. F is a recommended addition (the 4th) elsewhere on the page, so the F mini is not 'a note from your set' and does not sound 'the same tones' as anything she owns; the claim is contradicted by the owned note list. All other musical claims on the page hold: C, D, E, G, A is exactly a C major pentatonic; the stated -5 to +10 range matches; the full C major scale listing and the F=4th / B=major-7th degree names are correct; the E+10 Double Practitioner under the binaural line is a genuine binaural double product.

Music check — REFUTED
Minis section: "Other forms in notes from your set, a different way to sound the same tones" — includes a 5" F+5 Mini SuperGrade Practitioner.
F is not a note from her set. The page itself defines the set as exactly C+5, D0, E0, G-5, A+10 = C major pentatonic (C, D, E, G, A) — that headline claim recomputes correctly, as do F=the 4th and B=the major 7th of C major. But an F mini cannot 'sound the same tones' she owns; F is a proposed scale-completion note, not an owned tone, so the minis-section set-membership claim is false as applied. All seven other audited pages draw minis/forks/pyramids exclusively from owned notes, so this is a genuine deviation, not the engine's intended pattern. Everything else on the page survived: pentatonic exact (5/5, no better match), C major scale spelling, deeper-octave headings all genuinely deeper per tags (E 3rd<4th, G 3rd<4th, D 2nd<4th), E+10 double-practitioner binaural pick, span-line arithmetic.

Voice

FAIL	You have the pentatonic core (C, D, E, G, A); these add the 4th and the major 7th, opening it into the full scale R4 — unexplained degree jargon; headings "F (the 4th)", "B (the major 7th)".
FAIL	(C, D, E, G, A); these add B7 — semicolon in copy (same template sentence).